{"ok":true,"data":{"product":{"brand":"Bubble Skincare","name":"Cosmic Silk Hydrating Milky Toner","slug":"bubble-skincare-cosmic-silk-hydrating-milky-toner","product_url":"/products/bubble-skincare-cosmic-silk-hydrating-milky-toner","brand_url":"/brands/bubble-skincare","subcategory":"toner","formulation":null,"finish":null,"price_tier":"drugstore","enriched_price":"$16","enriched_price_usd":16,"retailers":["Amazon","Target","Walmart","CVS"],"key_ingredients":["Ceramides","Oleic Acid","Linoleic Acid","Arnica","Allantoin","4D Hyaluronic Acid Blend","Maple Sap Water"],"claims":["hydrates","smooths","plumps","improves radiance","soothes"],"consensus_summary":"Bubble Skincare's Cosmic Silk Hydrating Milky Toner is a hydrating formula that one creator loves for prepping skin before makeup. It's described as a fantastic formula at an affordable price point. No criticisms were mentioned in the available feedback.","gtin":null,"shades":[]},"signal":{"total_mentions":3,"holy_grail_count":0,"loves_it_count":2,"worth_trying_count":0,"mentions_count":0,"mixed_count":0,"not_recommended_count":1,"unsponsored_count":3,"sponsored_count":0},"caveats":{"mixed_evidence":false,"single_creator":false,"no_price_data":false,"has_negative":true,"negative_note":"1 creator did not recommend this product."},"tags":{"claims":[],"attributes":[{"tag":"hydrating","label":"Hydrating","group":"attribute","polarity":"positive","mention_count":3,"product_count":1,"source_type":"creator_quote","sample_quote":"I do know that I really, really love this for hydrating the skin before makeup.","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"charissedaily","creator_name":"Charisse Daily","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@charissedaily","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010","video_title":"Ranking viral milky skin toners best to worst","video_date":"2026-04-25"},{"creator_handle":"rudiberry","creator_name":"Rudi Berry","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rudiberry","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMODE6W2xD0","video_title":"My 2026 empties are top tier","video_date":"2026-03-14"},{"creator_handle":"shelbyannbell","creator_name":"SHELBY ANN","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shelbyannbell-l1r","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yn_uIfvLQTs","video_title":"Skin prep for makeup I hated","video_date":"2025-06-01"}]},{"tag":"easy_to_use","label":"Easy to use","group":"attribute","polarity":"positive","mention_count":2,"product_count":1,"source_type":"creator_quote","sample_quote":"I do know that I really, really love this for hydrating the skin before makeup.","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"rudiberry","creator_name":"Rudi Berry","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rudiberry","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMODE6W2xD0","video_title":"My 2026 empties are top tier","video_date":"2026-03-14"},{"creator_handle":"shelbyannbell","creator_name":"SHELBY ANN","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shelbyannbell-l1r","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yn_uIfvLQTs","video_title":"Skin prep for makeup I hated","video_date":"2025-06-01"}]},{"tag":"lightweight","label":"Lightweight","group":"attribute","polarity":"positive","mention_count":2,"product_count":1,"source_type":"creator_quote","sample_quote":"I would say it's really a close dupe to the Rhode, but I like the Rhode one a bit better because it feels cooling and lighter.","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"charissedaily","creator_name":"Charisse Daily","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@charissedaily","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010","video_title":"Ranking viral milky skin toners best to worst","video_date":"2026-04-25"},{"creator_handle":"rudiberry","creator_name":"Rudi Berry","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rudiberry","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMODE6W2xD0","video_title":"My 2026 empties are top tier","video_date":"2026-03-14"}]}],"good_for":[],"best_for":[],"value":[{"tag":"value_for_money","label":"Value for money","group":"value","polarity":"positive","mention_count":3,"product_count":1,"source_type":"creator_quote","sample_quote":"It is a fantastic formula and it is affordable price point.","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"charissedaily","creator_name":"Charisse Daily","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@charissedaily","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010","video_title":"Ranking viral milky skin toners best to worst","video_date":"2026-04-25"},{"creator_handle":"rudiberry","creator_name":"Rudi Berry","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rudiberry","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMODE6W2xD0","video_title":"My 2026 empties are top tier","video_date":"2026-03-14"},{"creator_handle":"shelbyannbell","creator_name":"SHELBY ANN","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shelbyannbell-l1r","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yn_uIfvLQTs","video_title":"Skin prep for makeup I hated","video_date":"2025-06-01"}]}],"warnings":[{"tag":"fast_absorbing","label":"Fast-absorbing","group":"attribute","polarity":"negative","mention_count":1,"product_count":1,"source_type":"creator_quote","sample_quote":"This also absorbs the slowest compared to the other four milky toners that I'm comparing today, so definitely give this time to absorb before putting on your makeup.","warning_text":"creators flagged issues with fast-absorbing","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"charissedaily","creator_name":"Charisse Daily","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@charissedaily","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010","video_title":"Ranking viral milky skin toners best to worst","video_date":"2026-04-25"}]},{"tag":"easy_to_use","label":"Easy to use","group":"attribute","polarity":"negative","mention_count":1,"product_count":1,"source_type":"creator_quote","sample_quote":"This also absorbs the slowest compared to the other four milky toners that I'm comparing today, so definitely give this time to absorb before putting on your makeup.","warning_text":"fiddly to use","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"charissedaily","creator_name":"Charisse Daily","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@charissedaily","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010","video_title":"Ranking viral milky skin toners best to worst","video_date":"2026-04-25"}]},{"tag":"sensitive","label":"Sensitive skin","group":"skin_type","polarity":"negative","mention_count":1,"product_count":1,"source_type":"creator_quote","sample_quote":"It's also not good if you are prone to clogged pores.","warning_text":"may not suit sensitive skin","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"charissedaily","creator_name":"Charisse Daily","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@charissedaily","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010","video_title":"Ranking viral milky skin toners best to worst","video_date":"2026-04-25"}]}]},"creators":[{"handle":"shelbyannbell","display_name":"SHELBY ANN","profile_url":"/creators/shelbyannbell","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@shelbyannbell-l1r","specialty":[],"years_active":1,"subscriber_count":13500,"endorsement_strength":"loves it","is_sponsored":false,"video_titles":["Skin prep for makeup I hated"],"quotes":[{"text":"This actually isn't a new milky toner. You guys have seen me use it a few times.","timestamp_start":55.12,"timestamp_end":60.8,"timestamp_start_formatted":"0:55","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yn_uIfvLQTs&t=55s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["repurchase","long-term use"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Really love this.","timestamp_start":74,"timestamp_end":76.22857142857143,"timestamp_start_formatted":"1:14","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yn_uIfvLQTs&t=74s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["holy grail"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It is a fantastic formula and it is affordable price point.","timestamp_start":66.799,"timestamp_end":74,"timestamp_start_formatted":"1:06","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yn_uIfvLQTs&t=66s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["value","formula"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I do know that I really, really love this for hydrating the skin before makeup.","timestamp_start":71.2,"timestamp_end":76.88,"timestamp_start_formatted":"1:11","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yn_uIfvLQTs&t=71s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["hydration","prep","ease of use"],"mentions_variant":null}]},{"handle":"rudiberry","display_name":"Rudi Berry","profile_url":"/creators/rudiberry","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@rudiberry","specialty":[],"years_active":null,"subscriber_count":73600,"endorsement_strength":"loves it","is_sponsored":false,"video_titles":["My 2026 empties are top tier"],"quotes":[{"text":"I am highly recommending to everyone who wants to try like a true milky toner.","timestamp_start":479.64,"timestamp_end":483.92,"timestamp_start_formatted":"7:59","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMODE6W2xD0&t=479s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["recommendation","milky toner"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"This is essentially like the Rhode Glazing Milk, but much cheaper.","timestamp_start":483.92,"timestamp_end":491.32,"timestamp_start_formatted":"8:03","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMODE6W2xD0&t=483s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["dupe","budget-friendly","comparison"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"This is like a true hydrating milky toner. I really like it. It's thin, it's lightweight. It feels super luxe and hydrating on the skin.","timestamp_start":516.24,"timestamp_end":524.16,"timestamp_start_formatted":"8:36","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMODE6W2xD0&t=516s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["hydrating","lightweight","luxurious feel"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"This would be great under makeup as well.","timestamp_start":532.96,"timestamp_end":538.6,"timestamp_start_formatted":"8:52","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMODE6W2xD0&t=532s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["under makeup","prep"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I think it's a great way to lean into trying a milky toner before you spend a lot of money on one.","timestamp_start":537.04,"timestamp_end":540.76,"timestamp_start_formatted":"8:57","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMODE6W2xD0&t=537s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["budget-friendly","introductory"],"mentions_variant":null}]},{"handle":"charissedaily","display_name":"Charisse Daily","profile_url":"/creators/charissedaily","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@charissedaily","specialty":["beauty content creator","professional beauty reviewer"],"years_active":11,"subscriber_count":40500,"endorsement_strength":"not recommended","is_sponsored":false,"video_titles":["Ranking viral milky skin toners best to worst"],"quotes":[{"text":"This one is the Bubble Cosmic Silk Hydrating Milky Toner.","timestamp_start":835.08,"timestamp_end":844.56,"timestamp_start_formatted":"13:55","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=835s","sentiment":null,"topics":[],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"This one feels very hydrating at first, but not super plumping.","timestamp_start":840.36,"timestamp_end":851.88,"timestamp_start_formatted":"14:00","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=840s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["hydration"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I would say it's really a close dupe to the Rhode, but I like the Rhode one a bit better because it feels cooling and lighter.","timestamp_start":848.56,"timestamp_end":859,"timestamp_start_formatted":"14:08","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=848s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["texture","lightweight"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"With this one, I can really feel the heaviness on my skin.","timestamp_start":859,"timestamp_end":867.56,"timestamp_start_formatted":"14:19","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=859s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["texture"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"The hydration is in the mid-level, but again, for my skin type, I just didn't like that heavy feel.","timestamp_start":864.16,"timestamp_end":872.6,"timestamp_start_formatted":"14:24","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=864s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["hydration","texture"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"The texture is also very milky, almost like a lotion. And again, a bit heavy for my liking.","timestamp_start":920.72,"timestamp_end":928.72,"timestamp_start_formatted":"15:20","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=920s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["texture"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"This one also feels slightly tacky at first, but once it dries down, it feels very smooth after a few minutes.","timestamp_start":926.24,"timestamp_end":934.839,"timestamp_start_formatted":"15:26","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=926s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["texture","blendability"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"When it comes to barrier, it's pretty decent. It has soothing ingredients, like helps calm, but not deep repair.","timestamp_start":934.839,"timestamp_end":942.4,"timestamp_start_formatted":"15:34","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=934s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["skin barrier","hydration"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"The finish is a natural glow, not totally glass skin, but I've applied so much, so I find that this one actually is giving like a glass skin finish, right?","timestamp_start":945.24,"timestamp_end":951.32,"timestamp_start_formatted":"15:45","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=945s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["glow","finish"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"This also absorbs the slowest compared to the other four milky toners that I'm comparing today, so definitely give this time to absorb before putting on your makeup.","timestamp_start":956.8,"timestamp_end":966.12,"timestamp_start_formatted":"15:56","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=956s","sentiment":"cautionary","topics":["absorption","ease of use"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"This is way cheaper than the Rhode one, but generally, it's mid-range.","timestamp_start":974.28,"timestamp_end":980.92,"timestamp_start_formatted":"16:14","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=974s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["value"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Personally, I would splurge more for the Rhode.","timestamp_start":980.92,"timestamp_end":985.76,"timestamp_start_formatted":"16:20","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=980s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["value"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It also has coconut alkanes. I think that's why I find that it is very similar to Rhode.","timestamp_start":983.32,"timestamp_end":991.079,"timestamp_start_formatted":"16:23","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=983s","sentiment":"positive","topics":[],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It's also not good if you are prone to clogged pores.","timestamp_start":991.079,"timestamp_end":999.16,"timestamp_start_formatted":"16:31","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXmVzDdf010&t=991s","sentiment":"cautionary","topics":["sensitive skin"],"mentions_variant":null}]}],"limitations":["Evidence-tag coverage is creator-dependent. Absence of a skin tone, white-cast, fragrance-free, fungal-acne-safe, or pregnancy-safe tag means not stated, not false.","Evidence is from YouTube creators only — not clinical trials or dermatologist studies."]}}