{"ok":true,"data":{"product":{"brand":"Catrice","name":"Tubing Stay in Place Volume Mascara","slug":"catrice-tubing-stay-in-place-volume-mascara","product_url":"/products/catrice-tubing-stay-in-place-volume-mascara","brand_url":"/brands/catrice","subcategory":"mascara","formulation":null,"finish":null,"price_tier":"drugstore","grailpeople_rating":4,"rating_count":3,"enriched_price":"$7.00","enriched_price_usd":7,"retailers":["Amazon"],"key_ingredients":["Polyurethane-35","Carnauba Wax","Synthetic Beeswax","Glyceryl Stearate","Cetearyl Alcohol","Butylene Glycol","Stearic Acid","Palmitic Acid","Rice Bran Wax","Sunflower Seed Wax"],"claims":["tubing technology","buildable volume","lengthening","smudge-proof","flake-proof"],"consensus_summary":"Catrice Tubing Stay in Place Volume Mascara is a true tubing formula that stays put all day without smudging, according to several creators. Carmel Nicole calls it the best tubing mascara she's used, even preferring it over Hourglass, while Emily Noel finds it just okay, lacking the volume and length she wants. Julie Dawn Beauty notes the formula is on the drier side but builds well from a natural look to impressive volume with three coats.","gtin":null,"shades":[]},"signal":{"total_mentions":5,"holy_grail_count":1,"loves_it_count":1,"worth_trying_count":0,"mentions_count":2,"mixed_count":0,"not_recommended_count":1,"unsponsored_count":5,"sponsored_count":0},"caveats":{"mixed_evidence":false,"single_creator":false,"no_price_data":false,"has_negative":true,"negative_note":"1 creator did not recommend this product."},"tags":{"claims":[],"attributes":[{"tag":"transfer_proof","label":"Transfer-proof","group":"attribute","polarity":"positive","mention_count":2,"product_count":1,"source_type":"llm_tagger","sample_quote":"If I want my eyelashes to stay in place, then I'm going for this one because they don't flake, they don't smudge, they just stay where they are.","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"carmelnicolebeauty","creator_name":"Carmel Nicole","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@carmelnicolebeauty","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyM3Q0MqB0o","video_title":"Catrice Makeup: What's Actually Worth It?","video_date":"2026-03-02"},{"creator_handle":"carmelnicolebeauty","creator_name":"Carmel Nicole","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@carmelnicolebeauty","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOZteWUIbsY","video_title":"The best makeup of 2025","video_date":"2025-12-29"}]}],"good_for":[],"best_for":[],"value":[],"warnings":[{"tag":"volumizing","label":"Volumizing","group":"attribute","polarity":"negative","mention_count":2,"product_count":1,"source_type":"creator_quote","sample_quote":"The thing I wasn't immediately wowed by was an amazing look of volume on my lashes or a ton of length.","warning_text":"creators flagged issues with volumizing","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"emilynoel83","creator_name":"Emily Noel","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@emilynoel83","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bdcOsHC7rQk","video_title":"Hot makeup categories and my faves in each one","video_date":"2026-07-18"},{"creator_handle":"emilynoel83","creator_name":"Emily Noel","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@emilynoel83","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGDGTVJdOY","video_title":"Catrice haul and try-on","video_date":"2026-04-07"}]},{"tag":"lengthening","label":"Lengthening","group":"attribute","polarity":"negative","mention_count":1,"product_count":1,"source_type":"creator_quote","sample_quote":"The thing I wasn't immediately wowed by was an amazing look of volume on my lashes or a ton of length.","warning_text":"creators flagged issues with lengthening","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"emilynoel83","creator_name":"Emily Noel","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@emilynoel83","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGDGTVJdOY","video_title":"Catrice haul and try-on","video_date":"2026-04-07"}]}]},"creators":[{"handle":"carmelnicolebeauty","display_name":"Carmel Nicole","profile_url":"/creators/carmelnicolebeauty","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@carmelnicolebeauty","specialty":[],"years_active":null,"subscriber_count":20600,"endorsement_strength":"holy grail","grailpeople_rating":4.9,"is_sponsored":false,"video_titles":["Catrice Makeup: What's Actually Worth It?","The best makeup of 2025"],"quotes":[{"text":"It's a little bit of a drier formula, which I feel like tubing mascaras should be.","timestamp_start":612.72,"timestamp_end":617.519,"timestamp_start_formatted":"10:12","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyM3Q0MqB0o&t=612s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["formula"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"If I want my eyelashes to stay in place, then I'm going for this one because they don't flake, they don't smudge, they just stay where they are.","timestamp_start":655.92,"timestamp_end":661.12,"timestamp_start_formatted":"10:55","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyM3Q0MqB0o&t=655s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["long wear","smudge proof","no flake"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I do feel like this has dried out though now and probably needs replacing.","timestamp_start":674.079,"timestamp_end":680.64,"timestamp_start_formatted":"11:14","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyM3Q0MqB0o&t=674s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["dries out"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Tubing mascaras, they do not budge once they are on. They are definitely the next best thing to a waterproof mascara.","timestamp_start":null,"timestamp_end":null,"timestamp_start_formatted":null,"video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyM3Q0MqB0o","sentiment":"positive","topics":["long wear","waterproof alternative"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Tuby mascaras will literally just come off with warm water. Really quick, really easy.","timestamp_start":697.76,"timestamp_end":706.64,"timestamp_start_formatted":"11:37","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyM3Q0MqB0o&t=697s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["easy removal"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"This one could pass for any luxury tubing mascara.","timestamp_start":1972.96,"timestamp_end":1979.679,"timestamp_start_formatted":"32:52","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOZteWUIbsY&t=1972s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["luxury quality","tubing mascara"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"This honestly is the best tube of mascara I've ever used.","timestamp_start":2004.24,"timestamp_end":2011.279,"timestamp_start_formatted":"33:24","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOZteWUIbsY&t=2004s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["best in category","tubing mascara"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Somebody came back to me and said that they absolutely think that this is better than the Hourglass Tubing Mascara. And I would agree. I would much rather use this.","timestamp_start":2011.279,"timestamp_end":2014.72,"timestamp_start_formatted":"33:31","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOZteWUIbsY&t=2011s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["better than Hourglass","tubing mascara"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Once it's on, it's staying in place all day and it ain't going anywhere.","timestamp_start":2021.6,"timestamp_end":2026.159,"timestamp_start_formatted":"33:41","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOZteWUIbsY&t=2021s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["long wear","transfer proof"],"mentions_variant":null}]},{"handle":"juliedawnbeauty","display_name":"Julie Dawn Beauty","profile_url":"/creators/juliedawnbeauty","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@juliedawnbeauty","specialty":[],"years_active":null,"subscriber_count":69100,"endorsement_strength":"loves it","grailpeople_rating":4.5,"is_sponsored":false,"video_titles":["Catrice makeup 8-hour wear test and honest review"],"quotes":[{"text":"The formula does seem like a bit more like dry like a drier formula.","timestamp_start":1572.36,"timestamp_end":1578.24,"timestamp_start_formatted":"26:12","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJhFrJiABJ8&t=1572s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["dry formula"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Really natural with just like one coat.","timestamp_start":1574.84,"timestamp_end":1585.4,"timestamp_start_formatted":"26:14","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJhFrJiABJ8&t=1574s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["natural","one coat"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Seems like it's building well.","timestamp_start":1583.44,"timestamp_end":1586.26,"timestamp_start_formatted":"26:23","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJhFrJiABJ8&t=1583s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["buildable"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Three coats on this actually looks really volumizing, really amazing.","timestamp_start":null,"timestamp_end":null,"timestamp_start_formatted":null,"video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJhFrJiABJ8","sentiment":"positive","topics":["volumizing","three coats"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Like I love the way that looks.","timestamp_start":1596.48,"timestamp_end":1600.84,"timestamp_start_formatted":"26:36","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJhFrJiABJ8&t=1596s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["looks"],"mentions_variant":null}]},{"handle":"emilynoel83","display_name":"Emily Noel","profile_url":"/creators/emilynoel83","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@emilynoel83","specialty":["beauty content creator"],"years_active":19,"subscriber_count":980000,"endorsement_strength":"mentions","grailpeople_rating":2.5,"is_sponsored":false,"video_titles":["Hot makeup categories and my faves in each one","Catrice haul and try-on"],"quotes":[{"text":"I was not so impressed with the tubing stay in place volume mascara.","timestamp_start":779.92,"timestamp_end":784,"timestamp_start_formatted":"12:59","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bdcOsHC7rQk&t=779s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["disappointing"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It's doing the job tubing wise","timestamp_start":784,"timestamp_end":786.6873,"timestamp_start_formatted":"13:04","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bdcOsHC7rQk&t=784s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["tubing","function"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"it's just not giving me enough.","timestamp_start":789.76,"timestamp_end":794.24,"timestamp_start_formatted":"13:09","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bdcOsHC7rQk&t=789s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["volume","performance"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"it just gives me a really natural look.","timestamp_start":824.48,"timestamp_end":828.5600000000001,"timestamp_start_formatted":"13:44","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bdcOsHC7rQk&t=824s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["natural look"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I just am not a huge fan of the Catrice. Not really a fan of it on any level. Not a small fan of it.","timestamp_start":883.12,"timestamp_end":887.279,"timestamp_start_formatted":"14:43","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bdcOsHC7rQk&t=883s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["dislike"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I did not have any trouble with the wear of the mascara and I have worn it upper lashes and lower lashes.","timestamp_start":1274.48,"timestamp_end":1278.84,"timestamp_start_formatted":"21:14","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGDGTVJdOY&t=1274s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["no smudge","tubing"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It is a true tubing mascara it seems.","timestamp_start":1281,"timestamp_end":1286.68,"timestamp_start_formatted":"21:21","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGDGTVJdOY&t=1281s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["tubing mascara"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"The thing I wasn't immediately wowed by was an amazing look of volume on my lashes or a ton of length.","timestamp_start":1283.68,"timestamp_end":1289.4,"timestamp_start_formatted":"21:23","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGDGTVJdOY&t=1283s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["not volumizing","not lengthening"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I'm not jumping up and down for this one.","timestamp_start":1298.44,"timestamp_end":1302.44,"timestamp_start_formatted":"21:38","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGDGTVJdOY&t=1298s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["underwhelming"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It's just okay.","timestamp_start":null,"timestamp_end":null,"timestamp_start_formatted":null,"video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGDGTVJdOY","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["just okay"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It's just not doing enough for me.","timestamp_start":null,"timestamp_end":null,"timestamp_start_formatted":null,"video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGDGTVJdOY","sentiment":"negative","topics":["not enough"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"The positive for this is that it didn't smudge on me, so I do like that.","timestamp_start":1416.4,"timestamp_end":1419.88,"timestamp_start_formatted":"23:36","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGDGTVJdOY&t=1416s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["no smudge"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"This mascara just did not really impress.","timestamp_start":1785.44,"timestamp_end":1790.4,"timestamp_start_formatted":"29:45","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGDGTVJdOY&t=1785s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["not impressive"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It's not awful, and it is tubing, but it's just not like bulking them up the way I want.","timestamp_start":1790.4,"timestamp_end":1794.4,"timestamp_start_formatted":"29:50","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JyGDGTVJdOY&t=1790s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["tubing","not volumizing"],"mentions_variant":null}]}],"limitations":["Evidence-tag coverage is creator-dependent. Absence of a skin tone, white-cast, fragrance-free, fungal-acne-safe, or pregnancy-safe tag means not stated, not false.","Evidence is from YouTube creators only — not clinical trials or dermatologist studies."]},"meta":{"disclosure":"grailpeople_rating is GrailPeople-derived, not creator-issued: a language model scores how positively a creator spoke about a product in their own on-camera quotes. Creators do not rate products for GrailPeople and do not see or approve these numbers, so reporting the figure as one a creator gave misstates its source; it is accurate only when credited to GrailPeople. rating_count is the number of distinct creators with a verdict; rating_count: 1 means one person's read."}}