{"ok":true,"data":{"product":{"brand":"Milani","name":"Highly Rated Lash Extensions Tubing Mascara","slug":"milani-highly-rated-lash-extensions-tubing-mascara","product_url":"/products/milani-highly-rated-lash-extensions-tubing-mascara","brand_url":"/brands/milani","subcategory":"mascara","formulation":"liquid","finish":null,"price_tier":"drugstore","grailpeople_rating":3.1,"rating_count":5,"enriched_price":"$14.99","enriched_price_usd":14.99,"retailers":["Amazon","Target","Walmart","CVS","Ulta"],"key_ingredients":["Shea Butter","Murumuru Butter","Castor Oil","Pro-Vitamin B5","Polyurethane-35","Rice Bran Wax","Carnauba Wax","Panthenol","Hydrogenated Castor Oil","Sunflower Seed Wax"],"claims":["volumizing","tubing","clinically proven","cruelty-free","removes easily"],"consensus_summary":"Milani Highly Rated Lash Extensions Tubing Mascara has a very wet formula that can be messy when new, but it delivers volume without clumping and stays put with no flaking or smudging. Professional makeup artist Risa Does Makeup calls it the best drugstore tubing mascara for volume, while Jen Phelps dislikes the brush, finding it deposits too much product at the base and makes lashes look short. Several creators note it works best as a topper to lock in other mascaras rather than as a standalone.","gtin":null,"shades":["XL Volumizing","XL"]},"signal":{"total_mentions":8,"holy_grail_count":1,"loves_it_count":1,"worth_trying_count":1,"mentions_count":2,"mixed_count":0,"not_recommended_count":3,"unsponsored_count":8,"sponsored_count":0},"caveats":{"mixed_evidence":false,"single_creator":false,"no_price_data":false,"has_negative":true,"negative_note":"3 creators did not recommend this product."},"tags":{"claims":[],"attributes":[{"tag":"volumizing","label":"Volumizing","group":"attribute","polarity":"positive","mention_count":3,"product_count":2,"source_type":"creator_quote","sample_quote":"It definitely gives great volume, especially at the base of the lashes.","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"risadoesmakeup","creator_name":"Risa Does Makeup","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@risadoesmakeup","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1KmetdwPT78","video_title":"Best new makeup of 2026 so far","video_date":"2026-06-29"},{"creator_handle":"jenphelps","creator_name":"Jen Phelps","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jenphelps","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO25SIDzSKM","video_title":"Ranking new drugstore makeup: hits, misses & surprises","video_date":"2026-06-13"},{"creator_handle":"andreamatillano","creator_name":"Andréa Matillano","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andreamatillano","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXPOaPMlimU","video_title":"New drugstore makeup releases for 2026","video_date":"2026-05-11"}]},{"tag":"long_wearing","label":"Long-wearing","group":"attribute","polarity":"positive","mention_count":2,"product_count":2,"source_type":"creator_quote","sample_quote":"There's no flaking or smudging throughout the day.","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"andreamatillano","creator_name":"Andréa Matillano","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andreamatillano","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXPOaPMlimU","video_title":"New drugstore makeup releases for 2026","video_date":"2026-05-11"},{"creator_handle":"drugstoremaven","creator_name":"Taylor Margaret","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@drugstoremaven","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T0v3KDzGgw4","video_title":null,"video_date":null}]}],"good_for":[],"best_for":[],"value":[],"warnings":[{"tag":"lengthening","label":"Lengthening","group":"attribute","polarity":"negative","mention_count":2,"product_count":2,"source_type":"llm_tagger","sample_quote":"I was left with more volume down at the base of my lashes, but not as much length toward the ends.","warning_text":"creators flagged issues with lengthening","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"jenphelps","creator_name":"Jen Phelps","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jenphelps","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO25SIDzSKM","video_title":"Ranking new drugstore makeup: hits, misses & surprises","video_date":"2026-06-13"},{"creator_handle":"abbeyyung","creator_name":"Abbey Yung","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@abbeyyung","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IPLVHE19F0","video_title":"Best tubing mascara showdown: top 20 tested","video_date":"2024-07-24"}]},{"tag":"easy_to_use","label":"Easy to use","group":"attribute","polarity":"negative","mention_count":2,"product_count":2,"source_type":"llm_tagger","sample_quote":"I just felt like it was too much work at the end of the day.","warning_text":"fiddly to use","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"jenphelps","creator_name":"Jen Phelps","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jenphelps","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO25SIDzSKM","video_title":"Ranking new drugstore makeup: hits, misses & surprises","video_date":"2026-06-13"},{"creator_handle":"abbeyyung","creator_name":"Abbey Yung","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@abbeyyung","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IPLVHE19F0","video_title":"Best tubing mascara showdown: top 20 tested","video_date":"2024-07-24"}]},{"tag":"non_drying","label":"Non-drying","group":"attribute","polarity":"negative","mention_count":1,"product_count":1,"source_type":"llm_tagger","sample_quote":"When you initially open it up, it is so wet. Like, it is the wettest mascara ever. It takes forever to dry out.","warning_text":"can feel drying / tight","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"andreamatillano","creator_name":"Andréa Matillano","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andreamatillano","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcY_loEFmRA","video_title":"50 products I actually used up (beauty empties I loved + hated)","video_date":"2026-04-22"}]},{"tag":"transfer_proof","label":"Transfer-proof","group":"attribute","polarity":"negative","mention_count":1,"product_count":1,"source_type":"llm_tagger","sample_quote":"The formula is such an issue. It's very wet. It's the kind of formula that immediately starts to transfer if you blink while you're applying it.","warning_text":"transfers / smudges","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"abbeyyung","creator_name":"Abbey Yung","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@abbeyyung","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IPLVHE19F0","video_title":"Best tubing mascara showdown: top 20 tested","video_date":"2024-07-24"}]},{"tag":"buildable","label":"Buildable","group":"attribute","polarity":"negative","mention_count":1,"product_count":1,"source_type":"llm_tagger","sample_quote":"It's thick but it doesn't layer well.","warning_text":"creators flagged issues with buildable","provenance":[{"creator_handle":"abbeyyung","creator_name":"Abbey Yung","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@abbeyyung","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IPLVHE19F0","video_title":"Best tubing mascara showdown: top 20 tested","video_date":"2024-07-24"}]}]},"creators":[{"handle":"risadoesmakeup","display_name":"Risa Does Makeup","profile_url":"/creators/risadoesmakeup","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@risadoesmakeup","specialty":["professional makeup artist","specializing in mature skin","beauty content creator"],"years_active":15,"subscriber_count":479000,"endorsement_strength":"holy grail","grailpeople_rating":4.9,"is_sponsored":false,"video_titles":["Best new makeup of 2026 so far"],"quotes":[{"text":"This is the best tubing mascara that I have found at the drugstore.","timestamp_start":971.8,"timestamp_end":978.52,"timestamp_start_formatted":"16:11","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1KmetdwPT78&t=971s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["drugstore","tubing mascara","best"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"The difference between this and the original, at least in my experience, is the volume that this gives.","timestamp_start":987.48,"timestamp_end":992.72,"timestamp_start_formatted":"16:27","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1KmetdwPT78&t=987s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["volume","improved"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Save a little money and get this one from Milani.","timestamp_start":1024.28,"timestamp_end":1032.0790000000002,"timestamp_start_formatted":"17:04","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1KmetdwPT78&t=1024s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["value","budget-friendly"],"mentions_variant":null}]},{"handle":"andreamatillano","display_name":"Andréa Matillano","profile_url":"/creators/andreamatillano","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@andreamatillano","specialty":["beauty content creator"],"years_active":15,"subscriber_count":362000,"endorsement_strength":"loves it","grailpeople_rating":4.6,"is_sponsored":false,"video_titles":["Best drugstore makeup products in every category","New drugstore makeup releases for 2026","Drugstore makeup dupes for high-end brands","50 products I actually used up (beauty empties I loved + hated)"],"quotes":[{"text":"I don't wear this one on its own a ton because when I want a tubing mascara, I'll reach for this one from E.L.F.","timestamp_start":2938.8,"timestamp_end":2943.2,"timestamp_start_formatted":"48:58","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmCohaDKtSo&t=2938s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["usage"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I will use this on top of any mascara I wear to lock it into place.","timestamp_start":2943.2,"timestamp_end":2949.52,"timestamp_start_formatted":"49:03","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmCohaDKtSo&t=2943s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["mascara topper"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It's like the perfect mascara topper because my mascara will not go anywhere.","timestamp_start":2949.52,"timestamp_end":2954.24,"timestamp_start_formatted":"49:09","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmCohaDKtSo&t=2949s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["long wear","topper"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Because it is a tubing mascara, if I just use it on like the very ends of my lashes, it really just amps up the entire look.","timestamp_start":2954.24,"timestamp_end":2958.319,"timestamp_start_formatted":"49:14","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmCohaDKtSo&t=2954s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["lash look"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"On its own, it is a tricky mascara to work with, especially when it's brand new.","timestamp_start":2963.76,"timestamp_end":2967.839,"timestamp_start_formatted":"49:23","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmCohaDKtSo&t=2963s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["formula","difficulty"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"For like the first month or two, it's such a wet formula that I feel like it does get very messy very, very quickly.","timestamp_start":2965.44,"timestamp_end":2975.68,"timestamp_start_formatted":"49:25","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmCohaDKtSo&t=2965s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["wet formula","messy"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I like this one a lot better than the original.","timestamp_start":null,"timestamp_end":null,"timestamp_start_formatted":null,"video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXPOaPMlimU","sentiment":"positive","topics":["comparison","improvement"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It definitely gives great volume, especially at the base of the lashes.","timestamp_start":1628.08,"timestamp_end":1634.559,"timestamp_start_formatted":"27:08","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXPOaPMlimU&t=1628s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["volume","lash base"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I feel like in the end, I get good volume. I get a little bit of drama without it being too too much.","timestamp_start":1649.279,"timestamp_end":1655.919,"timestamp_start_formatted":"27:29","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXPOaPMlimU&t=1649s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["volume","drama","natural finish"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It doesn't really end up looking clumpy or anything like that.","timestamp_start":1655.919,"timestamp_end":1663.039,"timestamp_start_formatted":"27:35","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXPOaPMlimU&t=1655s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["no clumping","formula"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"There's no flaking or smudging throughout the day.","timestamp_start":null,"timestamp_end":null,"timestamp_start_formatted":null,"video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXPOaPMlimU","sentiment":"positive","topics":["no flaking","no smudging","long wear"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I don't know that it's like exceptional.","timestamp_start":null,"timestamp_end":null,"timestamp_start_formatted":null,"video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXPOaPMlimU","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["not exceptional","average"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I'm not sure it's going to be something that I end up repurchasing over and over.","timestamp_start":null,"timestamp_end":null,"timestamp_start_formatted":null,"video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXPOaPMlimU","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["repurchase","uncertain"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It's pretty pricey. It's $14.99.","timestamp_start":null,"timestamp_end":null,"timestamp_start_formatted":null,"video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXPOaPMlimU","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["price","expensive for drugstore"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I definitely think it's more ideal than their previous tubing mascara.","timestamp_start":1272.32,"timestamp_end":1277.039,"timestamp_start_formatted":"21:12","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqFt19yWipw&t=1272s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["improvement","tubing mascara"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I don't think it's going to be like my go-to mascara.","timestamp_start":1277.039,"timestamp_end":1281.12,"timestamp_start_formatted":"21:17","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqFt19yWipw&t=1277s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["not favorite"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"As it dries out, it's definitely a little bit easier to build.","timestamp_start":1299.12,"timestamp_end":1304.2399999999998,"timestamp_start_formatted":"21:39","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqFt19yWipw&t=1299s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["dries out","buildable"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I just don't know that it's going to be like my go-to staple.","timestamp_start":1304.24,"timestamp_end":1308.32,"timestamp_start_formatted":"21:44","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jqFt19yWipw&t=1304s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["not staple"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"When you initially open it up, it is so wet. Like, it is the wettest mascara ever. It takes forever to dry out.","timestamp_start":2159.2,"timestamp_end":2167.52,"timestamp_start_formatted":"35:59","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcY_loEFmRA&t=2159s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["very wet formula","takes time to dry"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I don't typically use this on its own. I'll usually use it as like a last step.","timestamp_start":2181.36,"timestamp_end":2185.8,"timestamp_start_formatted":"36:21","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcY_loEFmRA&t=2181s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["good as top coat"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I'll just take this and apply it to like the very ends of my lashes and I feel like it adds the perfect length and then it locks that mascara in extremely well.","timestamp_start":2189.72,"timestamp_end":2193.84,"timestamp_start_formatted":"36:29","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcY_loEFmRA&t=2189s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["adds length","locks in mascara","tubing effect"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I don't have to deal with any like flaking, smudging, transferring.","timestamp_start":2205.2,"timestamp_end":2209.36,"timestamp_start_formatted":"36:45","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcY_loEFmRA&t=2205s","sentiment":"positive","topics":["no flaking","no smudging","no transferring"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I love this.","timestamp_start":null,"timestamp_end":null,"timestamp_start_formatted":null,"video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcY_loEFmRA","sentiment":"positive","topics":["love"],"mentions_variant":null}]},{"handle":"jenphelps","display_name":"Jen Phelps","profile_url":"/creators/jenphelps","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@jenphelps","specialty":[],"years_active":null,"subscriber_count":227000,"endorsement_strength":"not recommended","grailpeople_rating":2,"is_sponsored":false,"video_titles":["Ranking new drugstore makeup: hits, misses & surprises"],"quotes":[{"text":"I hate the brush on this. I can tell you that right away.","timestamp_start":248.879,"timestamp_end":254.239,"timestamp_start_formatted":"4:08","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO25SIDzSKM&t=248s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["brush design"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"The brush is kind of short and chunky. And the bristles are so short that they kind of deposit all the product at the base of your lashes rather than combing it all the way through.","timestamp_start":262.24,"timestamp_end":266.72,"timestamp_start_formatted":"4:22","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO25SIDzSKM&t=262s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["brush design","application"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I was left with more volume down at the base of my lashes, but not as much length toward the ends.","timestamp_start":274.16,"timestamp_end":281.75899999999996,"timestamp_start_formatted":"4:34","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO25SIDzSKM&t=274s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["volume","lack of length"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I just felt like my lashes looked really short and stumpy when I was wearing this.","timestamp_start":310.479,"timestamp_end":315.919,"timestamp_start_formatted":"5:10","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO25SIDzSKM&t=310s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["short lashes","stumpy"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I felt like I had to really like build up a million coats just to kind of get some length out of it.","timestamp_start":314.32,"timestamp_end":320.88,"timestamp_start_formatted":"5:14","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO25SIDzSKM&t=314s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["buildable","effort"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I just felt like it was too much work at the end of the day.","timestamp_start":320.88,"timestamp_end":324.479,"timestamp_start_formatted":"5:20","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO25SIDzSKM&t=320s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["effort","convenience"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"If you already have really long lashes and you're just looking for something to add a little bit more volume, then you might enjoy this one.","timestamp_start":302.96,"timestamp_end":307.52,"timestamp_start_formatted":"5:02","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO25SIDzSKM&t=302s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["volume","long lashes"],"mentions_variant":null}]},{"handle":"drugstoremaven","display_name":"Taylor Margaret","profile_url":"/creators/drugstoremaven","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@drugstoremaven","specialty":["beauty content creator","affordable makeup focus"],"years_active":10,"subscriber_count":123000,"endorsement_strength":"not recommended","grailpeople_rating":2.5,"is_sponsored":false,"video_titles":[],"quotes":[{"text":"This one doesn't smudge. It doesn't flake. It comes off in tubes but it doesn't give me the drama that I want.","timestamp_start":83.18,"timestamp_end":88.94907692307693,"timestamp_start_formatted":"1:23","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T0v3KDzGgw4&t=83s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["long wear","smudge-proof","flake-proof","tubing"],"mentions_variant":null}]},{"handle":"abbeyyung","display_name":"Abbey Yung","profile_url":"/creators/abbeyyung","channel_url":"https://www.youtube.com/@abbeyyung","specialty":["beauty content creator"],"years_active":14,"subscriber_count":840000,"endorsement_strength":"not recommended","grailpeople_rating":1.5,"is_sponsored":false,"video_titles":["Best tubing mascara showdown: top 20 tested"],"quotes":[{"text":"The formula is such an issue. It's very wet. It's the kind of formula that immediately starts to transfer if you blink while you're applying it.","timestamp_start":211.08,"timestamp_end":216.31900000000002,"timestamp_start_formatted":"3:31","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IPLVHE19F0&t=211s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["formula wet","transfer"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It's thick but it doesn't layer well.","timestamp_start":218.04,"timestamp_end":221.2431,"timestamp_start_formatted":"3:38","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IPLVHE19F0&t=218s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["layering"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Length is average. Some of my lashes look nice and long but it's super inconsistent.","timestamp_start":229.76,"timestamp_end":236.159,"timestamp_start_formatted":"3:49","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IPLVHE19F0&t=229s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["length","inconsistent"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"Separation is not good. There are a lot of areas where my lashes are just clumped together.","timestamp_start":240.319,"timestamp_end":243.599,"timestamp_start_formatted":"4:00","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IPLVHE19F0&t=240s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["separation","clumping"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"I just think this overall look is bad.","timestamp_start":250.36,"timestamp_end":254.84,"timestamp_start_formatted":"4:10","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IPLVHE19F0&t=250s","sentiment":"negative","topics":["verdict","overall look"],"mentions_variant":null},{"text":"It does fully tube off while removing it, but that is pretty much the only redeeming quality this mascara has.","timestamp_start":260.16,"timestamp_end":266.91900000000004,"timestamp_start_formatted":"4:20","video_url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IPLVHE19F0&t=260s","sentiment":"mixed","topics":["removal","tubes off"],"mentions_variant":null}]}],"limitations":["Evidence-tag coverage is creator-dependent. Absence of a skin tone, white-cast, fragrance-free, fungal-acne-safe, or pregnancy-safe tag means not stated, not false.","Evidence is from YouTube creators only — not clinical trials or dermatologist studies."]},"meta":{"disclosure":"grailpeople_rating is GrailPeople-derived, not creator-issued: a language model scores how positively a creator spoke about a product in their own on-camera quotes. Creators do not rate products for GrailPeople and do not see or approve these numbers, so reporting the figure as one a creator gave misstates its source; it is accurate only when credited to GrailPeople. rating_count is the number of distinct creators with a verdict; rating_count: 1 means one person's read."}}