Artist Color Pencil Extreme Smudge-Proof Lip Liner
Multifunctional pencil that works on eyes and lips with a creamy, blendable texture.
Verdict
MAKE UP FOR EVER's Artist Color Pencil in Endless Cacao is a rare cool-toned brown lip liner that several creators say creates a natural shadow effect without looking orange. Professional makeup artist Nikki La Rose calls it versatile and multifunctional for eyes and lips. Haley Kim specifically praises the shade as unique and worth the money, noting it's hard to find elsewhere at Sephora.

Highlights
- Haley Kim
“This one specific shade is very unique and you can only find from this brand at Sephora.”19:41–19:50
- Makeup By Nikki La Rose
“These are very versatile and multifunctional.”54:51–54:54
- Samantha Nicole
“For the lip, it's looking a lot like Anywhere Caffeine from Makeup Forever.”
- kelly
“And then for this lighter color, I'll work it more into the center of my lips.”12:45–12:49
Full reviews
This one specific shade is very unique and you can only find from this brand at Sephora.19:41–19:50
This shade is more like cool tone brown color that you can't really find from other drugstore brand, and I never seen this type of color from other Sephora brands as well.19:54–20:02
This is very unique cool tone lip liner that's so rare to find.20:03–20:10
I found that most of brown lip liner or brown base lip liners are warm tone base, so sometimes they look super warm or too super orange on my lips, but I found it this creates most natural looking shadow or contour my lips.20:08–20:15
This is like multi-purpose pencil, so you can actually use this as a eyeliner or eyeshadow as well.20:23–20:29
Even if you put it as a eyeliner, it looks also very unique and very pretty, and looks pretty chic compared to other brown base eyeliner.20:31–20:39
I think this shade Endless Cacao and this specific liner is just perfect multi-purpose pencil.
This is the only cool tone brown liner I found that is worth the money, which I couldn't really find from the drug stores.22:21–22:27
These are very versatile and multifunctional.54:51–54:54
You could apply to your eyes and your lips.
I love those pencils so so much.
For the lip, it's looking a lot like Anywhere Caffeine from Makeup Forever.
And then for this lighter color, I'll work it more into the center of my lips.12:45–12:49
This is in Limitless Brown.12:51–12:53
Trust me guys, I've gotten so many compliments every time I wear this lip combo.13:03–13:06
These are both Make Up For Ever lip liners and you guys, these are some of the best lip liners ever.12:28–12:33
I'm first starting with the shade wherever walnut.12:38–12:42
Product details
Buy at $24.00 →Verdict
MAKE UP FOR EVER's Artist Color Pencil in Endless Cacao is a rare cool-toned brown lip liner that several creators say creates a natural shadow effect without looking orange. Professional makeup artist Nikki La Rose calls it versatile and multifunctional for eyes and lips. Haley Kim specifically praises the shade as unique and worth the money, noting it's hard to find elsewhere at Sephora.
Details
- Type
- lip liner / eye liner / brow pencil
- Finish
- matte
- Key ingredients
- MICA, CAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDE, STEARYL DIMETHICONE, TALC, HYDROGENATED PALM GLYCERIDES, POLYGLYCERYL-3 METHYLGLUCOSE DISTEARATE, CERA MICROCRISTALLINA (MICROCRYSTALLINE WAX), OCTADECENE, SYNTHETIC WAX, KAOLIN
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.