Product profile

MAKEUP BY MARIO

Lip Pencil

Toasty
1Mentions
1Creators
Price
Type
Finish
Retailers
Key ingredients

Creator evidence

holy grail · mid-range · everyday, sephora sale, holy grails, favorites
My favorite lip pencils at Sephora hands down are going to be the MAKEUP BY MARIO pencils.▶ 18:56–19:01
The shade Toasty is definitely the standout.
Toasty is a little bit more pink, a little bit more smoky, a little bit more defining than Almond.▶ 19:53–20:04
I like how I can really cheat the size of my lips with Toasty.▶ 20:05–20:10
I do like the cool pinkiness that Toasty has.
His lip liners, they are buttery, they are smooth, they are pigmented, there's no dragging, there's no pulling.▶ 20:12–20:17
It's such a beautiful lip liner formula.▶ 20:17–20:19
It's been one of my most used lip pencils.▶ 20:47–20:51
Source: Sephora Sale 2026 Holy Grails: My Favorite Products · Apr 2026