Lip Cheat Lip Liner
SUMMARY OF REVIEWS
Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat Lip Liner has a creamy, slightly waxy formula that sets to a long-lasting, transfer-proof finish, with several creators calling it their most repurchased liner. Professional makeup artist Lisa J notes it's a top-rated viral lip pencil, while Matilda on Video describes the Pillow Talk Medium shade as a warm berry pink that gives a "just bitten" look. The formula grips quickly, so blending time is limited, but it stays put through eating and drinking.
FULL REVIEWS
POSITIVE
Variant: Foxy Brown
- “The most beautiful brown tone. Also a great color that is a staple in my collection cuz it goes with everything”23:42–23:50
- “And these are very long-lasting”23:50–23:53
- Source: Sephora sale recommendations 2025: what's actually worth it - Oct 29, 2025
Variant: Iconic Nude
- “One of my most repurchased and most used lip liners in my entire collection”23:17–23:22
- “It is just the best lip liner. It goes with everything. gives that natural enhancement to my lips”23:22–23:30
- “I love this with glam with more simple makeup. It is just a non-stop forever repurchase for me”23:33–23:40
- Source: Sephora sale recommendations 2025: what's actually worth it - Oct 29, 2025
- “I love the convenience of this to having both the lip line to fill in with the other side or to line if I want it slightly lighter”27:53–27:58
- “This just lives in my purse and it's easy for touch-ups if I needed to touch up, but genuinely I've been staining my lips as of lately, so I don't really need to touch it up”28:01–28:07
- Source: Top 3 favorites in every makeup category 2025 - Sep 25, 2025
Variant: Foxy Brown
- “It's the perfect neutral brown on my lips. Not too dark, not too light, not too warm, and not too cool”28:52–29:00
- “The formula is great as well because it's creamy, but it sets. And once it sets, it doesn't really budge or move as much as traditional lip liners”29:01–29:07
- “I love Foxy Brown because it's the perfect neutral brown on my lips”28:52–28:57
- Source: Best makeup of 2025 - Dec 8, 2025
Variant: Iconic Nude
- “Very long-lasting and they will not slip off”3:28–3:32
- “They actually grip onto your lips”3:30–3:34
- “This feels a little bit more matte than the Kylie Comes Naturally shade that I just showed you, but it's within the same family as far as the tone”3:34–3:38
- “It gives me that perfect enhancement to my lips”
- “I love this with any type of gloss or lighter pink lipstick”3:46–3:52
- “This really does grip onto your lips when you apply it, so you don't have a lot of time to blend and really diffuse this in”3:50–3:55
- “Once you put it on, it's plastered onto your lips, but I love it because it is so long-wearing and it's transfer-proof”3:57–4:00
- “Charlotte Tilbury for the win”
- Source: The best lip liners and my go-to lip combos - Apr 15, 2026
Variant: Iconic Nude
Variant: Love Trap
- “I still really really love this”10:38–10:44
- “I've been able to use this quite a bit and I feel like it's dwindling down very much like the Pillow Talk 2 Medium”
- “They're just two tiny little lip liners that bring me so much joy”10:48–10:56
- “This one has like a really nice reddish tone to it that complements my skin tone really well or maybe like a berry tone”11:21–11:27
- “I have been reaching for this more than I have in the past”11:44–11:48
- “It works really well for a lot of looks”
- Source: Project Pan 2026 Update: Additions and Removals - Mar 19, 2026
Variant: Love Trap
- “Love Trap is described as a peachy brown, but on my skin tone, it doesn't pull peach at all”5:17–5:23
- “It has a touch of a rose in there”5:25–5:29
- “It's a step up from Iconic Nude cuz it's not as light, but it's also not as dark as a deep dark lip liner”5:29–5:33
- “I love how long-lasting this formula is”5:35–5:39
- “If you don't want to constantly be reapplying your lip liner, a Charlotte Tilbury lip liner is going to get you right every time”5:39–5:42
- Source: The best lip liners and my go-to lip combos - Apr 15, 2026
Variant: Pillow Talk Medium
- “I love this lip liner”9:42–9:45
- “I'm not even devastated that it's small cuz I already bought a backup”9:45–9:48
- “I really really love this and I've been using it a ton”10:01–10:08
- “It's just such an easy mindless product that I love that looks really good on my skin tone”10:08–10:15
- “It lasts a long time”
- “It goes so well with so many different lip looks”10:18–10:23
- “I also love it by itself. Like I love it as an all over lip color”10:21–10:28
- “It's just so pretty and it's just so nubby and cute and I freaking love it”10:25–10:33
- Source: Project Pan 2026 Update: Additions and Removals - Mar 19, 2026
Variant: Pillow Talk Medium
- “This lip liner has a huge following and cult shades like original Pillow Talk or iconic nude, but I'm more of a Pillow Talk medium person”8:18–8:24
- “This warm berry pink is perfect for just bitten color”8:26–8:34
- “It is creamy, but slightly waxy as it's designed to last, and it does”8:34–8:41
- Source: Reviewing bestselling beauty products from Sephora - Feb 17, 2026
Variant: Pillow Talk Medium
- “Pillow Talk Medium is the warm berry pink that feels far more me than original Dusty Rose Pillow Talk”4:06–4:10
- “This is the firmest formula here”4:13–4:17
- “It has a more traditional waxy feel”4:15–4:19
- “Good lasting power as a result”4:19–4:23
- “This shade is just such a good fit with the look I'm going for”4:26–4:29
- Source: Top blotted lipsticks and lip liners for Nina Park lip look - Feb 2, 2026
Variant: Iconic Nude
- “I love iconic nude too”25:43–25:47
- “If you have my skin tone and you're more into that kind of lip contoured look, iconic nude kind of gives you a little bit of like a shadow and then they set down budge proof and matte”25:47–25:52
- Source: Best luxury makeup in every category - May 16, 2026
- “I think we already know that is obviously a top rated lip liner, this is like a viral lip pencil and this was highly rated”26:42–26:47
- Source: I tried Sephora's highest rated makeup - Feb 21, 2026
Variant: Pillow Talk
- “They both glide on really well except the Charlotte Tilbury one has a little bit more tackiness to it which lets me know that it's going to last longer”
- Source: Drugstore dupes for high-end makeup - Jul 19, 2024
Variant: Iconic Nude
- “It is just the most beautiful nude shade that looks exactly like my natural lip color”2:28–2:36
- “I've tried many lip liners and the Charlotte Tilbury ones seem to have the most longevity”2:36–2:42
- Source: Huge self-care haul with viral products - Nov 25, 2024
Variant: Pillow Talk
- “These also last all day”10:32–10:35
- “I think I've gone through at least 20 of each”10:34–10:39
- “I keep them on rotation”10:39–10:43
- “I keep them stockpiled up cuz I can never run out”10:42–10:47
- “These are great”
- Source: Best Sephora Products You Need: Full Face + VIB Rouge Sale Haul - Apr 21, 2026
Variant: Pillow Talk
- “I love the Pillow Talk. Of course, it's beautiful. It's a very pinky. But, I love it”18:21–18:25
- “On the high end side, they are a little bit more waxy, so they don't blend as smoothly”19:12–19:19
- “The only thing that didn't wipe off is the Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk lip liner. Look at this. Do you hear that? I'm scrubbing. Guys. What do you mean it's not coming off and I'm scrubbing it?”
- Source: Luxury vs Drugstore Makeup Comparison - May 24, 2026
MIXED / NEGATIVE
No negative reviews yet — creators have only had good things to say.
WHAT CREATORS SAY
- Consensus
- 4.7 / 5 from 10 creator reviewsGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
- Features
- Long-wearing (12) · Easy to use (5) · Creamy (2) · Transfer-proof (2) · Matte finish (2)
- ⚠ harder to blend (1)
Product details
Details
- Type
- lip liner
- Finish
- matte
- Shade
- Iconic Nude
- Key ingredients
- Jojoba Seed Oil
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.
Links