Master Mascara
BUY IT HERE
MAKEUP BY MARIO Site →Amazon →Sephora →SUMMARY OF REVIEWS
MAKEUP BY MARIO Master Mascara is praised by professional makeup artist Ali Andreea for giving volume without adding texture, and Morgan Turner (former professional wedding makeup artist) says it's lightweight, holds a curl, and doesn't smudge. However, Sophie flags severe flaking, calling it the worst among her mascaras and noting it causes eye irritation. The formula splits opinion sharply: those who love it cite buildable, elegant results, while others find it unwearable due to flaking.
FULL REVIEWS
POSITIVE
- “I find that the Makeup by Mario mascara is exceptional”38:08–38:15
- “I can tell that that mascara was done by a makeup artist because it's everything that we love as makeup artists, we love about mascara. It gives you that very good volume without adding a lot of material, without adding a lot of texture on the eyelashes”38:13–38:17
- “When it comes to the clients, I like an elegant formula, right? One that I can build. And Makeup by Mario creates exactly that”38:39–38:44
- Source: Best makeup in 2025 - Jan 11, 2026
- “It's really lightweight on the lashes and it holds a curl, it builds volume, it has definition, it has everything I want in a mascara”33:00–33:05
- “It makes my lashes look good”33:20–33:24
- “It makes my friend's lashes who has lashes look incredible”33:25–33:29
- “If you like one that's lighter weight and holds a curl but gives a little bit of everything, you'll love this”33:29–33:32
- “Doesn't smudge”
- Source: Best makeup of 2025 (tried 400 products) - Dec 19, 2025
MIXED / NEGATIVE
- “They go on beautifully. I love the initial formula. I love the wand”19:05–19:10
- “This does not last. It will flake and get your eyeballs and itch and scratch”19:16–19:23
- “This flakes the most, I think, out of any of my mascaras”19:41–19:47
- Source: Sephora Sale 2026: What to Skip, Hidden Gems & Top Picks - Apr 10, 2026
WHAT CREATORS SAY
- Consensus
- 3.7 / 5 from 3 creator reviewsGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
- Features
- Volumizing (2)
- ⚠ doesn't last / fades through the day (1)
Product details
Details
- Type
- mascara
- Finish
- —
- Shade
- —
- Key ingredients
- ProVitamin B5, Castor Oil, High-Performance Polymer, vegan wax blend, olive oil, rice bran wax, sunflower seed wax
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.
Links