Stay Jelly Sheer Butter Balm
SUMMARY OF REVIEWS
L.A. Colors Stay Jelly Sheer Butter Balm is a tinted lip balm that Julie Dawn Beauty finds extremely moisturizing, with buildable pigment and a pretty peachy-pink or berry shade, calling it a dupe for Dior Lip Glow. However, Amanda Z (beauty content creator) describes it as a milky pink formula that is essentially mineral oil with pigments and looks awful on the lips. The balm requires frequent reapplication, but at Dollar Tree pricing, it's a budget-friendly option for those who like sheer, glossy color.
FULL REVIEWS
POSITIVE
Variant: Sheer Black Cherry
- “I find this tinted lip balm to be pretty much an exact dupe for the Dior lip glow in the shade berry”16:13–16:22
- “This is gorgeous for fall and for winter”16:39–16:45
- “This is also a great lipstick combo for anybody that's like a deep autumn or like a dark winter”16:47–16:53
- “I just think this is such a beautiful combo”
- Source: My Top Dollar Tree Lipsticks & Liners | Swatches + Best Combos - May 7, 2026
Variant: Sheer Peach
- “I love, love, love these tinted lip balms from L.A. Colors”6:55–7:04
- “They are so moisturizing”7:01–7:07
- “My two favorite shades in this line is in sheer peach and in sheer black cherry”7:04–7:11
- “I tend to wear the one in sheer peach and the one in sheer black cherry the most”7:14–7:19
- Source: My Top Dollar Tree Lipsticks & Liners | Swatches + Best Combos - May 7, 2026
Variant: Sheer Peach
- “I've decided that I want to use this LA Colors Shea Butter Lip Balm on top of this lip stain”6:25–6:30
- “This is going to make this a little bit more intense”
- Source: Full face of under $10 makeup fast everyday look - May 19, 2026
Variant: Sheer Peach
- “This is just been my go-to favorite”19:36–19:42
- “It's just a tinted lip balm and this is super moisturizing”19:40–19:44
- “As you can see it's got really good pigment”19:44–19:48
- “This lip balm is obviously like the type of product that you're going to have to reapply a lot throughout the day, but I really like this color. It's super moisturizing”19:42–19:45
- Source: Current go-to everyday look: top makeup under $5 - May 21, 2026
Variant: Sheer Peach
- “The formula is so moisturizing on these and I love the colors”39:07–39:15
- “They're pretty vibrant for just being a lip balm”39:12–39:18
- “You can build them up to have more color”39:27–39:32
- “That color is just super moisturizing. Like I think it's so pretty”41:18–41:26
- Source: Best dollar tree makeup products by category - Jun 9, 2026
Variant: Sheer Black Cherry
- “This other shade that I really love is in sheer black cherry, which is more of like a berry, like a purple berry”0:55–1:04
- “If you love a good affordable lip balm, definitely check these out at your Dollar Tree”1:04–1:10
- Source: Top lip products for summer - May 30, 2026
Variant: Sheer Peach
- “They are so moisturizing”
- “Such a pretty like peachy pinky coral”
- Source: Top lip products for summer - May 30, 2026
MIXED / NEGATIVE
- “This looks awful on the lips. It is so milky pink. It is essentially just mineral oil with pigments in it”33:45–33:50
- “This has got to go. There's no use in even sticking here”33:59–34:04
- Source: Lip balm ranking: top 7 picks from 30+ viral products - May 9, 2026
WHAT CREATORS SAY
- Consensus
- 4.5 / 5 from 8 creator reviewsGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
- Features
- Hydrating (3) · Sheer (2) · Pigmented (2) · Everyday (2)
- Value
- Value for money (2)
Product details
Details
- Type
- lip balm
- Finish
- glossy
- Shade
- Sheer Peach
- Key ingredients
- Meadowfoam seed oil
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.
Links