Eyes Up 24H Creamy Kajal Longwear Eyeliner
BUY IT HERE
Sarah Creal Site →Amazon →Sephora →SUMMARY OF REVIEWS
Sarah Creal Eyes Up 24H Creamy Kajal Longwear Eyeliner is a satin formula that several creators say outperforms Victoria Beckham's kajal in staying power. Professional makeup artist Ali Andreea notes it blends easily for a soft line, while Mandy Davis MUA warns it sets fast with less smudge time but calls it "more bulletproof" and ideal for waterline or hooded eyes. The everyday taupe shade is praised as a soft, long-lasting neutral that locks in after a brief creamy window.
FULL REVIEWS
POSITIVE
Variant: Everyday Taupe
- “Sarah Creal has absolutely captured me. I love these eyeliners”19:04–19:09
- “This everyday taupe shade is longlasting. It is creamy, so I can actually play with the formula and then it just locks in and it's such a soft color”19:17–19:26
- “It's really pretty for everyday, especially if you don't want like a full chocolate brown or a full black. It just gives me the illusion of a wing while being soft enough”19:26–19:38
- “The formula is just so easy to work with”19:43–19:48
- “Very even pigment”19:53–19:56
- Source: Best luxury makeup in every category - May 16, 2026
Variant: Everyday Matte Bronze
- “An incredible formula”
- “These are like the satin kajal eyeliners from Victoria Beckham except better somehow”25:07–25:10
- “They actually gosh darned stay put no matter what they're on top of, which is huge for me”25:25–25:32
- “My experience is that these are a lot more tenacious”25:46–25:51
- “I love that formula anyway. Now we just have more options”34:42–34:46
- Source: Trying new makeup from Violette_FR, Sarah Creal, Vieve, Guerlain, Givenchy, Byredo and more - May 5, 2026
Variant: Everyday Taupe
- “This is your everyday taupe. It's really really pretty with like a taupe mascara”25:49–25:55
- Source: Trying new makeup from Violette_FR, Sarah Creal, Vieve, Guerlain, Givenchy, Byredo and more - May 5, 2026
- “This I feel like is one of the only new eyeliners that I've tried in a really long time”
- “This is a really, really pretty shade”
- “It's a brown, but it isn't super super dark, so it's not pulling like it is a black, but it gives you a little bit of something”17:21–17:26
- “I love the Sarah Creal. Their um eyeliners are so pretty, and I feel like there's so many people that would really enjoy these. And I overall am a big fan of them”
- “The shade is so pretty because it I don't know how to explain it. It's just does a little something, but it isn't really really dark, which I appreciate”17:26–17:32
- “Huge fan of those”
- Source: Best new makeup I've tried recently - May 19, 2026
Variant: Matte Bronze
- “Sarah Creal sent me over their brand new liner shade. This is their new shade, matte bronze”11:08–11:15
- “I love the color”
- “They dry down a lot faster. There's less wiggle room as far as smudging them out, and they don't smudge as much”12:08–12:16
- “When I tell you I swatched this to post it on my stories, and it was on for maybe I don't know, two or three minutes before I went to rub it off with a makeup wipe, and I could barely get it off. These suckers do not move”12:21–12:25
- “I do think they're more bulletproof than the Victoria Beckham”12:37–12:41
- “While they're not as smudgeable, and they set down way faster, they are more bulletproof, and I do find that they're going to be better in the waterline than the Victoria Beckham”12:42–12:46
- “If you're someone who likes the waterline, or if you have super hooded eyes, and you find, you know, eyeliners transfer, or if you like to use them under your eyes like I'm about to do, but you find it smudges with your concealer, I truly don't think you're going to have that issue with these liners”12:50–12:53
- Source: My version of the best bronzed look - May 12, 2026
Variant: Matte Bronze
Variant: Copper
- “I have this at the base of my lashes. I like exactly for this reason that you can then blend and play whatever you want, however you want. Or you could also use it just like a line”35:01–35:07
- “This is very, very close to that and very beautiful”35:25–35:30
- Source: Best makeup in 2025 - Jan 11, 2026
MIXED / NEGATIVE
No negative reviews yet — creators have only had good things to say.
WHAT CREATORS SAY
- Consensus
- 4.6 / 5 from 6 creator reviewsGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
- Features
- Long-wearing (3) · Transfer-proof (2) · Easy to use (2) · Multitasking (2) · Natural / everyday (2)
Product details
Details
- Type
- eyeliner
- Finish
- —
- Shade
- —
- Key ingredients
- —
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.
Links