Jelly Much Eyeshadow Stick
SUMMARY OF REVIEWS
ColourPop's Jelly Much Eyeshadow Stick glides on with a cooling, gel-like feel and dries down without fallout or creasing. Several creators praise the high pigment load and versatility as a one-and-done shadow or topper, but Jen Phelps notes wear time is short — sparkle fades within 3-4 hours, leaving only glitter behind. Best suited as a glitter topper for short wear, not an all-day base.
FULL REVIEWS
POSITIVE
Variant: Diamond Girl
- “I cannot get enough of those”4:49–4:54
- “The first few shades I tried were very, very sheer. So, I don't know why, but I assumed the entire line was sheer, but it's not. They actually have such a good range”4:51–4:56
- “If you like that scattered glitter effect and you want more of an intense finish, they have those, too”4:58–5:05
- “It reminds me of Frog, the ColourPop SuperShock Shadow”7:15–7:21
- “Oh, it's so pretty”
- “You can just lightly dab it on, but you can very easily build it up, too”8:03–8:10
- “It layers really, really nicely”
- Source: Drugstore makeup dupes for high-end brands - Jun 15, 2026
- “They have that nice cooling feel to them”21:29–21:31
- “They do feel like a true gel”21:33–21:36
- “This type of product is just so easy to use”21:46–21:49
- “Glides on, dries down, there's no fallout, there's no creasing”21:51–21:53
- “These are definitely going to be more so topper shadows”22:50–22:52
- “These seem super sheer with like a ton of sparkle”
- “That is gorgeous”
- “The perfect amount of wet looking shine”23:20–23:20
- Source: Drugstore makeup outperforms high end - Jun 1, 2026
Variant: Big Energy
- “I've worn both, and I've really enjoyed both of them”27:04–27:08
- Source: New drugstore makeup first impressions and reviews - Jun 7, 2026
Variant: Kinda Busy
- “These actually have really high pigment load”25:20–25:24
- “It gives you a ton of pigment”
- “It looks really beautiful”25:46–25:48
- “I like the versatility of these because you can use it as a one-and-done type of eyeshadow or you can use this as an eyeshadow topper”25:48–25:52
- “I think that this is actually really fun and a great addition to ColourPop's cosmetic line”26:09–26:16
- “It is a really fun, cool feeling”26:20–26:24
- “I love the shade range that they came out with”26:24–26:27
- “I've worn both, and I've really enjoyed both of them”27:04–27:08
- Source: New drugstore makeup first impressions and reviews - Jun 7, 2026
Variant: Real Talk
- “This is absolutely gorgeous. This to me is giving more of like glitter topper in the shade specifically, but I really really enjoy it”42:26–42:31
- “I found when these do dry down, like I feel like the sparkle lasts for like a long time, and I don't feel like I get like glitter flop fallout all over my face”42:50–42:56
- Source: Full face of drugstore makeup - Jun 19, 2026
Variant: Offline
- “A stick is definitely like a much easier way to go”
- “I just love how smoothly these go on. Like they're very I mean you hardly have to press down and you get with some of the shades really nice color payoff”21:06–21:14
- “What I love about the formula is how thin it is. This is not the kind of eyeshadow stick that's going to drag on your lids. It's just super smooth. It almost feels like a serum in a stick. It has this cooling sensation as it goes on”21:27–21:36
- “I didn't find that I've had to blend these really at all”21:48–21:53
- “These don't have the longest wear time. So, they're probably best suited as a topper”22:00–22:08
- “They pretty much disappeared and just left some glitter particles behind maybe within like 3 or 4 hours”22:37–22:41
- “I think they're super fun and they make really great eye looks. It's just the wear time is the only thing that's kind of bringing them down a little bit”22:48–22:55
- Source: Ranking new drugstore makeup: hits, misses & surprises - Jun 13, 2026
MIXED / NEGATIVE
No negative reviews yet — creators have only had good things to say.
WHAT CREATORS SAY
- Consensus
- 4.4 / 5 from 6 creator reviewsGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
- Features
- Easy to use (3) · Sheer (2) · Pigmented (2) · Buildable (2) · Shimmer (2)
- ⚠ doesn't last / fades through the day (1)
Product details
Details
- Type
- eyeshadow stick
- Finish
- shimmer
- Shade
- Big Energy
- Key ingredients
- —
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.
Links