Highly Rated Fan Club Fanning Mascara
SUMMARY OF REVIEWS
Milani Highly Rated Fan Club Fanning Mascara bulks up lashes quickly in one coat and does not flake, according to Emily Noel. However, Andréa Matillano reports it gets clumpy fast, deposits too much product, and weighs lashes down rather than lifting or curling them. The formula divides opinion: it works well if you prioritize fast volume and curl hold, but risks clumping if you prefer a fanned-out look.
FULL REVIEWS
POSITIVE
- “I really love this mascara. This is an honorable mention”20:02–20:05
- “This is how my lashes look. Don't they look so good? I did curl them. My lower lashes are popping”20:11–20:14
- Source: Top 10 Best Drugstore Products of 2026 - May 12, 2026
- “If I can get a really good curl, I'll be content with Milani fan club because hopefully then the curl won't be dropping and this in itself will just in a quick coat give me what I want as far as the bulk on the lashes”9:41–9:47
- Source: No-fail makeup routine for time constraints - Apr 21, 2026
- “I really love how quickly this builds up”4:57–5:02
- Source: Spring lip ideas: combos, pearl finish, stains - Mar 31, 2026
- “I feel like it bulks up my lashes quickly, which is a quality I really want”
- “It does build up really fast, which keeps my curl from dropping so much, and that I like”
- “If I get a really good curl on them, like this mascara looks so nice on me”
- “This does a lot of work in one coat”
- “This one does not flake”
- “The Milani does a good job for me”
- Source: Elite drugstore makeup GRWM that looks more expensive - May 9, 2026
MIXED / NEGATIVE
- “I love the original highly rated mascara. That is one of my absolute favorites”5:31–5:38
- Source: Worst makeup of 2026 - Apr 29, 2026
- “This had a tendency to get clumpy very, very quickly”5:59–6:06
- “I don't find that you get like that nice fanned out look”
- “The actual brush just deposits too much product”6:43–6:48
- “I get volume, but it's like volume bordering on looking super clumpy”6:45–6:52
- “It ends up weighing my lashes down, and it definitely does not lift them and curl them and hold them into place well”7:03–7:09
- “I just feel like the marketing is kind of off with this product”
- Source: Worst makeup of 2026 - Apr 29, 2026
WHAT CREATORS SAY
- Consensus
- 3.5 / 5 from 6 creator reviewsGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
- Features
- Easy to use (2)
- ⚠ creators flagged issues with volumizing (1)
- ⚠ doesn't last / fades through the day (1)
Product details
Details
- Type
- mascara
- Finish
- —
- Shade
- —
- Key ingredients
- Sunflower Seed Wax, Synthetic Beeswax, Jojoba Esters, Shea Butter, Panthenol, Tocopherol, Ascorbyl Palmitate, Rice Bran Wax, Acacia Senegal Gum, Glycerin
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.
Links