Pencil Eyeliner

Not bad. That's so creamy. If this does not smear everywhere, then this is great. This is a really rich black pencil and it went on so nicely.16:53–17:06

This eyeliner is really good.6:57–7:00

I used this in my last Dollar Tree video. It is super creamy and dark.6:58–7:04

It doesn't smudge. Honestly, I don't even know how they did it because it's so affordable, but it's not waterproof or anything, but it doesn't smear throughout the day.7:02–7:06