Automatic Eyeliner Pencil
SUMMARY OF REVIEWS
L.A. Colors Automatic Eyeliner Pencil has a felt tip applicator that one creator compares favorably to Wet n Wild and NYX Epic Ink liners, calling it "not flimsy, not too stiff." The same creator found the burgundy shade made her eyes look red and irritated, so she didn't love it for that reason. Another creator wished she had picked up the charcoal shade instead, suggesting color choice matters.
FULL REVIEWS
POSITIVE
Variant: Better Than Burgundy
- “I have tried L.A. Colors auto eyeliner. I thought it was okay, so maybe this one will be even better”5:51–5:56
- “It is like a true kind of burgundy”6:07–6:12
- “I don't know actually if I like that with my eye color and my eyes. I think it might actually make my eyes look like they're red to be honest”6:11–6:19
- “Not a bad eyeliner. It's just the color”6:24–6:27
- “This kind of just makes my eyes look very red, pink eyeish. I don't like it”6:29–6:36
- “I did try that L.A. Colors auto eyeliner. I don't think this is bad. I just didn't like that burgundy color with my eye color”17:34–17:37
- “I just felt like it instead of making them pop, it just made them look so red and a little irritated. So, I didn't love this for that reason”17:36–17:44
- Source: Full Face of New Dollar Tree Makeup Hits & Misses - Nov 10, 2025
Variant: Black
- “I already love this eyeliner”5:26–5:31
- “This is exactly how I like my brush applicators”5:29–5:37
- “This applicator kind of reminds me of a Wet n Wild eyeliner or even my NYX Epic Ink liner, which is one of my favorites”5:34–5:39
- “Has a nice felt tip. This is really good. New eyeliner alert here from L.A. Colors”5:42–5:46
- “This L.A. Colors liquid liner is top tier. Another one of my favorite products at the Dollar Tree that I have tried”17:44–17:50
- “I really like the Dollar Tree eyeliner because it's not flimsy, it's not too stiff, it's the perfect brush applicator”18:01–18:05
- Source: Full Face of New Dollar Tree Makeup Hits & Misses - Nov 10, 2025
Variant: Charcoal
- “I was saying in that video I wish I would have picked up the charcoal eyeliner”14:33–14:40
- Source: Dollar Tree Makeup & Skincare Haul with Swatches - May 12, 2026
MIXED / NEGATIVE
No negative reviews yet — creators have only had good things to say.
WHAT CREATORS SAY
- Consensus
- 3.5 / 5 from 2 creator reviewsGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
Product details
Details
- Type
- eyeliner
- Finish
- —
- Shade
- Better Than Burgundy
- Key ingredients
- —
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.
Links