Master Pigment Pro Eyeliner Pencil
BUY IT HERE
MAKEUP BY MARIO Site →Amazon →Sephora →SUMMARY OF REVIEWS
MAKEUP BY MARIO's Master Pigment Pro Eyeliner Pencil is a gel-like, longwearing formula that glides on easily and blends out for a soft or defined look. Professional makeup artist Nikki La Rose calls it "phenomenal" and notes the taupe shade works well for diffusing concealer, while several creators praise the included brush tip for precise blending. The shade Perfect Brown is described as a versatile earthy brown that makes green and hazel eyes pop, and it's a go-to for waterline use according to Tamara Renaye.
FULL REVIEWS
POSITIVE
Variant: Black
- “Really, really, really love Makeup by Mario”6:37–6:43
- “When it comes to eyeliner for the waterline, Makeup by Mario is all I use”16:25–16:30
- Source: My 2025 Makeup Favourites - Oct 30, 2025
- “These are incredibly longwearing, gel-like, easy to glide on and really high impact”50:36–50:40
- Source: Allure Best of Beauty according to me - Oct 11, 2025
Variant: Taupe, Soft Brown
- “These are gel, longwearing, neutral, great for daytime”10:02–10:06
- “They're phenomenal pencils”37:03–37:05
- Source: Allure Best of Beauty according to me - Oct 11, 2025
Variant: Taupe
- “makeup by mario taupe eyeliner n20s blend out the rest of the edges of the concealer and diffuse it”
- Source: Quick makeup for early mornings - Mar 9, 2026
- “Makeup by mario tan one of my absolute favorites”
- Source: Grwm in Austin - Mar 27, 2026
Variant: Bronze
- “I think this brings green and hazel eyes more make it more pop popping”13:09–13:22
- “It's really pretty this bronzy color. Definitely recommend”13:24–13:28
- “I love this color on the eye so much”13:48–13:51
- Source: Full face of stick makeup on dry skin with real texture close-up - May 18, 2026
Variant: Perfect Brown
- “The Makeup by Mario Master Pigment Pro pencil in the shade perfect brown has been fantastic”35:38–35:50
- “It's actually kind of similar to this, a cool toned brown, and I'm able to get a very fine line, but I'm also able to smudge it out if I want to”35:51–35:57
- “It's like a true wooden pencil liner”35:57–36:00
- “Also, it has a brush tip that is shockingly good”35:33–35:35
- Source: Best of beauty 2025 into 2026: makeup favorites, new essentials, longtime holy grails - Dec 30, 2025
Variant: Perfect Brown
- “This is a beautiful brown. It's called the perfect brown. It's a perfect earthy brown”2:09–2:14
- “I always start with lining on the inside of the eye. So the inner rim tight lining”2:06–2:09
- “This will also help to make the lashes look thicker”2:30–2:34
- “I'm flipping the pencil over now, and I'm going to just use that brush just to blend in the outer corners”2:47–2:52
- “I'm just blending this into the lid. I'm going to go right into that corner there. I like to apply a little bit more into this corner because it really shapes the eye beautifully”2:49–2:58
- “Now that we've done this liner, this also helps you to sort of not use as much eyeshadows because you're getting the definition now step by step”3:03–3:08
- Source: Makeup by Mario masterclass: Mario's signature makeup - Oct 28, 2025
MIXED / NEGATIVE
No negative reviews yet — creators have only had good things to say.
WHAT CREATORS SAY
- Consensus
- 4.8 / 5 from 7 creator reviewsGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
- Features
- Easy to use (4) · Long-wearing (2) · Blendable (2)
Product details
Details
- Type
- eyeliner pencil
- Finish
- —
- Shade
- Perfect Brown
- Key ingredients
- Isododecane, Trimethylsiloxysilicate, Synthetic Wax, Polymethyl Methacrylate, Polyethylene, Caprylyl Methicone, Diisostearyl Malate, Synthetic Fluorphlogopite, Stearoxymethicone/Dimethicone Copolymer, Copernicia Cerifera (Carnauba) Wax
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.
Links