NYC

Vanilla Hydrating Lip Mask

SUMMARY OF REVIEWS

Creators keep circling back to NYC Vanilla Hydrating Lip Mask when they want something they can trust.

FULL REVIEWS

POSITIVE

3.5Vanilla Hydrating Lip Mask
  • “This one actually smells like vanilla, but it's not like a good vanilla, unfortunately. It's like a really chemically vanilla”8:03–8:07
  • “Texturally, this one actually feels quite similar to the Lanes one”8:09–8:15
  • “I think sensation wise and the way it looks is actually this is quite similar to the actual product they were trying to go for compared to a lot of these other ones where I'm like, 'Girl, it's not even the same.'”8:11–8:19
  • “But the smell isn't good. It's like a really manufactured vanilla”8:24–8:28
  • “This little NYC sleep mask I did feel was actually very similar to the Lanz consistency”15:27–15:33
  • “I don't think it's going to be as hydrating necessarily, but I do think that it was pretty darn good and it felt very, very, very similar”15:33–15:37
  • “The smell is not as amazing as the vanilla one from Lanesh, but for five bucks, a pretty good dupe”15:38–15:45
  • Source: I bought every viral Five Below makeup dupe - Nov 9, 2025

MIXED / NEGATIVE

No negative reviews yet — creators have only had good things to say.

WHAT CREATORS SAY

Consensus
3.5 / 5 from 1 creator reviewGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
  • scent some found off-putting (1)
Product details

Details

Type
lip mask
Finish
Shade
Key ingredients

Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.