Colorful Eyeshadow
Summary of Reviews
Sephora Collection's Colorful Eyeshadow earns praise from professional makeup artist Lisa J for its "really pretty" mattes and shimmers, with a ton of shade options and great quality. However, Geek Out of Water, a beauty content creator, strongly criticizes the packaging, saying the shades are beautiful but the hard-to-open case will stop her from using them. If you can tolerate difficult packaging, the formula itself delivers, but the usability flaw is a real dealbreaker for some.
Full Reviews
Positive
Variant: 600 to the Moon and Back
- “It's really pretty”
- “The formula's nice. Both the matte and the shimmers are great”7:28–7:31
- “The mattes are really beautiful and they have a ton of shade options”7:32–7:40
- “They're great quality”
- Source: Sephora Collection Picks: Affordable Products That Perform Like High-End - Apr 17, 2026
Variant: Scented Candle
- “I can't stand how hard these are to open. And I don't understand why they're so hard to open”9:53–9:57
- “That alone will get me to stop using these because I mean, I'm just not going to do this every time I'm trying to do my makeup”10:05–10:09
- “I do love the shade, but oh, the packaging sucks”10:46–10:52
- “Shade is beautiful, but the packaging will prevent me from using it”10:55–11:00
- “Oh, it's a good color, though. I do like this shade”
- Source: New drugstore makeup from Elf, Maybelline, and Beauty Creations - Aug 13, 2026
Variant: Shock Choc
- “Well, actually, this works kind of well being brownish cuz it'll go with that highlight and then it won't look totally mismatched”11:55–12:00
- Source: New drugstore makeup from Elf, Maybelline, and Beauty Creations - Aug 13, 2026
Variant: Milky Way
- “This is a really pretty champagne shade. So, it's not too gold and not silver. It's just like right in the middle”3:50–3:54
- Source: My Updated Full Glam Makeup Routine - May 16, 2025
Variant: Mocha Latte
- “just a little bit lower”3:44–3:48
- Source: My Updated Full Glam Makeup Routine - May 16, 2025
Mixed / Negative
No negative reviews yet — creators have only had good things to say.
What creators say
- Consensus
- 3.9 / 5 from 2 creator reviewsGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
- Features
- Full glam (2)
- ⚠ packaging issues noted (1)
Product details
Details
- Type
- single eyeshadow
- Finish
- shimmer
- Shade
- 600 to the Moon and Back
- Key ingredients
- Mica, Synthetic Fluorphlogopite, Titanium Dioxide, Squalane, Calcium Sodium Borosilicate, Dimethicone, Hydrogenated Styrene/Isoprene Copolymer, Iron Oxides, Caprylyl Glycol, Ethylhexylglycerin
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.
Links