Lines Liberated 24H Waterproof Eyeliner
Buy it here
Amazon →Ulta →Sephora →Nordstrom →Summary of Reviews
Yves Saint Laurent's Lines Liberated 24H Waterproof Eyeliner is a creamy, quick-drying pencil that stays put all day without smudging, yet removes easily. Tati praises its color, glide, and waterline performance, calling it "one of the best liners I have ever used," while EatSleepMascara notes its complex brown with a plum tint and long wear through Zoom meetings. Elena Rachitskaya highlights its beginner-friendly flexibility and the built-in brush for sharp wings, though chrissstttiiine remains unimpressed, saying she's "not loyal to it."
Full Reviews
Positive
Variant: 02 Deconstructed Brown
- “I don't get excited about eyeliners that often”
- “I bought this during my $1,500 face try-on, and oh my gosh, I am down to like, there's almost nothing left here”2:50–2:57
- “I cannot even remember the last time I used a liner down to the little itty-bitty nothing end”2:55–3:05
- “The color, perfection. The glide, perfection”3:13–3:18
- “The way this goes in the waterline and does not smudge everywhere, perfection”3:16–3:23
- “It is one of the best liners I have ever used, hands down”3:34–3:38
- “Also, shockingly not terrible to take off, either”3:35–3:41
- “This is one of those oddballs where it stays put all day, but then when you go to remove it, it removes very very easily”3:47–3:50
- Source: 10 Beauty Products I'd Buy Again and Again - Jun 8, 2026
Variant: 2 Brown
- “This is actually really nice to work with. Very creamy, so there's no lies there”15:32–15:36
- “The dry down seems to be pretty quick and I feel like it's not going to glob all over the place. So I'm going to go ahead and say this is a winner”15:36–15:40
- “The YSL liner is amazing. I love it”21:29–21:34
- Source: World's most expensive makeup - Mar 30, 2026
Variant: 1
- “Out of all waterproof pencils this year, only two truly survived the everything with me”
- “It's long-lasting, slightly creamy, almost like butter, sets in a few seconds, and I recommend it to everyone who is just learning how to do eyeliners”13:16–13:21
- “It's flexible, easy to manipulate, and perfect for stretching that line into a thin lifted wing”13:26–13:35
- “On the other end of the pencil, you have a sharp brush that pulls the wing out and creates the cleanest, sharpest line”13:42–13:47
- “You can even use that brush to outline the lips with a red lipstick or to shape brows”13:50–13:55
- Source: My Most-Used Makeup Products of 2025 - Nov 28, 2025
Variant: Waterproof / 2
- “You can see I've been wearing this literally since 8:00 a.m. It is now freaking 5:30, 6:00 p.m. Something like that. No touch-ups”8:58–9:03
- “There is a hint of plum or purple in this brown that makes it really special”9:26–9:34
- “This is the eyeliner that I reach for because nothing screams smoky definition and like precise definition like this specific eyeliner”
- “When I'm in Zoom meetings, if I need to fake being alive and with the world in my demos and things like that, this is what I reach for. This makes my eyes look anime cartoon huge in Zoom meetings. Like, it's just it's incredible”
- “I really, really like this product. It is extremely longw wear”10:29–10:32
- “There is something about the shade of this that just reflects different and it gives me just a lot of joy because I love a complex brown”10:30–10:38
- Source: Best brown eyeliners - Sep 1, 2025
- “I'm not loyal to it. Not married to it”
- Source: GRWM with Saie Sale Favorites - May 24, 2026
Mixed / Negative
No negative reviews yet — creators have only had good things to say.
What creators say
- Consensus
- 4.7 / 5 from 3 creator reviewsGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
- Features
- Easy to use (4) · Long-wearing (3) · Creamy (2)
Product details
Details
- Type
- eyeliner
- Finish
- —
- Shade
- 02 Deconstructed Brown
- Key ingredients
- Cactus Fig Oil
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.
Links