EatSleepMascara's Favorites
“I have been exclusively using this as an eyeliner, and I freaking love this product, and it's from the drugstore, so it's totally reasonably priced…”
“This is one of the best liners out there…”
“You can see I've been wearing this literally since 8:00 a.m. It is now freaking 5:30, 6:00 p.m. Something like that. No touch-ups…”
“Victoria Beckham eyeliners are the softest of the softest of the most soft eyeliners out there that do a decent amount of not smudging or running throughout the day, assuming, of course, that you let it completely set on your eyes…”
“What I love about this eyeliner is look at how freaking tiny and precise this eyeliner is. It does not get more precise than this…”
Explore Similar Creators
juicyjasLip Liner · Eyeliner
The Clean Beauty CodeLip Liner · Contour
Makeup By Nikki La RoseEyeliner · Lip Liner
Kackie Reviews BeautyContour · Bronzer
Sophie 🎀Lip Liner · Contour
Lisa JLip Liner · Eyeliner
TatiEyeliner · Lip Liner
Ali AndreeaEyeliner · Contour
Emily NoelLip Liner · Eyeliner
Dacey CashLip Liner · EyelinerBrowse All Their Reviews
Variant: Less Traced
- “I have been exclusively using this as an eyeliner, and I freaking love this product, and it's from the drugstore, so it's totally reasonably priced”1:30–1:39
- “This one has a beautiful pink shift to it that just makes it that perfect amount of like cool tone smokiness that looks so beautiful on brown eyes”1:43–1:49
- “If I am looking for a soft brown, kind of a smokier softer, not super defined brown eyeliner, this is the one that I am reaching for”1:52–2:03
- “It also lasts all day long”2:07–2:10
- “As an eyeliner, freaking love this”2:18–2:22
- Source: Best brown eyeliners - Sep 1, 2025
Variant: Less Traced
- “I have been exclusively using this as an eyeliner, and I freaking love this product, and it's from the drugstore, so it's totally reasonably priced”1:30–1:39
- “This one has a beautiful pink shift to it that just makes it that perfect amount of like cool tone smokiness that looks so beautiful on brown eyes”1:43–1:49
- “If I am looking for a soft brown, kind of a smokier softer, not super defined brown eyeliner, this is the one that I am reaching for”1:52–2:03
- “It also lasts all day long”2:07–2:10
- “As an eyeliner, freaking love this”2:18–2:22
- Source: Best brown eyeliners - Sep 1, 2025
Variant: Killer Chocolate
- “This is one of the best liners out there”4:53–4:58
- “The shade killer chocolate is freaking stunning”5:07–5:14
- “This one is going to give you a little bit of that warmth. It leans almost slightly red in its tone that gives it just a little bit more of a balance to it”5:12–5:22
- “This one just gives you a little bit of hint of that of that red to just really make the brown pop in your eyes. Like they make everything just look super alive”5:22–5:34
- “I definitely get asked about this one when I'm out and like wandering around cuz people are like, 'Wow, like that's a really pretty brown eyeliner. Like which one are you wearing?”5:41–5:49
- “So this is definitely one that I would highly recommend checking out”5:55–5:58
- Source: Best brown eyeliners - Sep 1, 2025
Variant: Less Traced
- “I have been exclusively using this as an eyeliner, and I freaking love this product, and it's from the drugstore, so it's totally reasonably priced”1:30–1:39
- “This one has a beautiful pink shift to it that just makes it that perfect amount of like cool tone smokiness that looks so beautiful on brown eyes”1:43–1:49
- “If I am looking for a soft brown, kind of a smokier softer, not super defined brown eyeliner, this is the one that I am reaching for”1:52–2:03
- “It also lasts all day long”2:07–2:10
- “As an eyeliner, freaking love this”2:18–2:22
- Source: Best brown eyeliners - Sep 1, 2025
Variant: 9
- “What I love about this eyeliner is look at how freaking tiny and precise this eyeliner is. It does not get more precise than this”2:52–3:00
- “When you are looking for a tiny eyeliner, for those of us that have Asian eyes or if you have mono lids, this is exactly what you need because it is small enough to get in there right into your eyes and then be able to create the cutest, most perfect tiny little wing ever”2:57–3:08
- “And the product as a benefit is that it completely stays on all day long”3:21–3:29
- “And this eyeliner is so waterproof. When I wear this during the summer time, I'm just like, look at my pristine eyeliner that's still there at 10 p.m. Like, it's phenomenal”
- “I really like this one for when I want something that's just more a little bit more like autumn coated”3:54–4:04
- Source: Best brown eyeliners - Sep 1, 2025
Variant: 15
- “If I'm looking for something that's really going to give me that cool tone, I definitely will reach for number 15, which is that gorgeous, stunning, admittedly not totally brown eyeliner cuz it is a little bit more like grayish pink”4:11–4:18
- “I do still think it's really really stunning and it can kind of fall in the brownish but not really brown eyeliner, but still a really good find”4:30–4:34
- Source: Best brown eyeliners - Sep 1, 2025
Variant: Waterproof / 2
- “You can see I've been wearing this literally since 8:00 a.m. It is now freaking 5:30, 6:00 p.m. Something like that. No touch-ups”8:58–9:03
- “There is a hint of plum or purple in this brown that makes it really special”9:26–9:34
- “This is the eyeliner that I reach for because nothing screams smoky definition and like precise definition like this specific eyeliner”
- “When I'm in Zoom meetings, if I need to fake being alive and with the world in my demos and things like that, this is what I reach for. This makes my eyes look anime cartoon huge in Zoom meetings. Like, it's just it's incredible”
- “I really, really like this product. It is extremely longw wear”10:29–10:32
- “There is something about the shade of this that just reflects different and it gives me just a lot of joy because I love a complex brown”10:30–10:38
- Source: Best brown eyeliners - Sep 1, 2025
Variant: Terracotta
- “Victoria Beckham eyeliners are the softest of the softest of the most soft eyeliners out there that do a decent amount of not smudging or running throughout the day, assuming, of course, that you let it completely set on your eyes”7:19–7:26
- “This is a stunning shade”7:34–7:38
- “If you're looking for like a warm true terracotta brown that has like orange in it, here you go. This is exactly what she was going for”7:50–7:56
- “I like to wear this one as we go into the fall. Like, I will be reaching for this eyeliner a ton because this just gives me that look of like fall is here”7:59–8:06
- “I would say that this one actually almost somehow makes my pupils that are like dark cuz my pupils are dark brown. Um, I think it makes them a little bit lighter in a way just the way that it kind of reflects on my eyes”
- “This is a beautiful, beautiful eyeliner”8:37–8:41
- Source: Best brown eyeliners - Sep 1, 2025
Variant: Plum
- “It's going to give you a little bit more of that like grayish purpley shift to it. Almost a little bit pinkish to it that makes it so that when you're defining your eyes, it just kind of gives a softer focus to your liner”6:31–6:36
- “It's not going to be like as intense, but there's still enough definition to bring again the focus to your eyes. This is a really, really nice one”6:40–6:49
- “I will be candid with you that the Persona eyeliner I don't think is a 24-hour wear eyeliner, but it is a beautiful option if you have more mature lids and you're really worried about like tugging”6:52–6:58
- “You don't like the experience of having to like go back and forth on your eyes multiple times. Like this is a really good option to have”
- Source: Best brown eyeliners - Sep 1, 2025
Explore Product Reviews in Videos
Creator Snapshot
2KSubscribers
11 yearsOn YouTube
7Product reviews
beauty content creator, professional beauty reviewerTopics
About
makeup. food. coffee. snooze. repeat. full time presales director part time makeup reviewer thanks for watching ;)