Urban Decay

Urban Decay is a legacy brand that still delivers on long-wearing eye makeup and setting sprays, though not every product hits the same mark. The Tube Job Tubing Mascara is a clear anchor: it gives defined, lengthened lashes without flaking or smudging, and removes easily. But the All Nighter Setting Spray has a reformulation that some creators now find disappointing, and the Glaze-On Liquid Eyeshadows are widely criticized for drying down crackly and refusing to layer. The brand is best for someone who wants reliable tubing mascara or a dewy setting spray, but the rest of the line is uneven.