Super Stay Peel-Off Lip Liner
SUMMARY OF REVIEWS
Maybelline's Super Stay Peel-Off Lip Liner applies like a cream, dries matte, and stays put for over 10 hours, with one creator noting it survived a shower. However, By Kristina Studio (beauty content creator) warns the shade range is narrow and colors appear much deeper in person than in marketing photos. It works best as a defined lip liner rather than a diffused stain, and the peel-off step is purely aesthetic.
FULL REVIEWS
POSITIVE
Variant: Haze
- “This feels gentle on the lips while providing staining power that lasts”2:49–2:54
- “It has a free formula set in 5 minutes peels off seamlessly for up to 24-hour tattoo-like wear”2:54–2:58
- “I love that it peels so quickly and it peels like in one strip”18:21–18:27
- “After I did my makeup, I felt like the stain was gone”18:36–18:41
- “I love how they peel so seamlessly and I will say when I filled it in today it did stain a little more than yesterday”25:33–25:39
- “Really grew on me. I wasn't sure about them, but I just love how they stain and how they peel. The peeling part is so my favorite because it peels so evenly and neatly”28:12–28:16
- Source: 8 new makeup products 2-day wear test - May 25, 2026
Variant: Dawn
- “I wanted to fill in the lips just to see what the vibe was going to be after”23:32–23:37
- “It peels so seamlessly. I absolutely love it”24:02–24:06
- “I love how they peel so seamlessly and I will say when I filled it in today it did stain a little more than yesterday”25:33–25:39
- Source: 8 new makeup products 2-day wear test - May 25, 2026
Variant: Haze
- “It's a mask and then you wait a little bit and then you peel it off and you are left with a stain on the lips”0:28–0:32
- “It's really just for the aesthetic”0:33–0:36
- “The shade range is quite narrow”
- “The colors in the marketing photos are very different from what I've experienced in person”1:03–1:10
- “This comes out much much deeper on my lips than it looks in the marketing photos”1:10–1:16
- “This is high pigmentation for a stain”1:20–1:25
- “You only have to wait 5 minutes for the stain to really penetrate your lips”2:50–2:57
- “As a lip liner, this stayed all day, you guys”3:06–3:11
- Source: New drugstore makeup first impressions and reviews - Jun 7, 2026
Variant: Aura
- “Even this one is quite deep on me”
- Source: New drugstore makeup first impressions and reviews - Jun 7, 2026
MIXED / NEGATIVE
No negative reviews yet — creators have only had good things to say.
WHAT CREATORS SAY
- Consensus
- 4.3 / 5 from 4 creator reviewsGrailPeople ratings based on creator reviews.
- Features
- Easy to use (2) · Long-wearing (2)
- ⚠ creators flagged issues with wide shade range (1)
Product details
Details
- Type
- lip liner stain
- Finish
- natural
- Shade
- Haze
- Key ingredients
- vitamin E
Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission.
Links