5 Most Overrated Skincare Products — And What to Buy Instead
La Roche-Posay$18.99- “I think it's a really really nice restorative repairing cream”▶ 0:47
- “It's really really good if you're dealing with like minor scrapes to the face or like post-procedure skin”▶ 1:23
- “The texture is very, very thick”▶ 1:40
- “It's very thick emollient like and it creates a nice occlusive layer on the skin”▶ 1:49
- “For a lot of people, especially those with oily combination skin like myself, it can feel kind of heavy, very greasy”▶ 2:01
- “Sometimes people said it's made their breakouts worse”▶ 2:12
- “I feel like people do pose this as the healing ointment for everything”▶ 2:13
- “It's more so like for special occasions”
- “That zinc leaves me with a little bit of a white cast and it really really does look like a night mask kind of situation for me”
- “Cicaplast amazing if you're post-procedure, dealing with really dry, damaged skin, or have very easily sensitized skin with some breakouts”▶ 2:01
SKIN1004$18.90- “It's lightweight”
- “It's fast absorbing and more suitable for like daily use”▶ 3:03
- “The B5 tea tree cream also targets like acne prone skin with tea tree extract and tea tree oil which bring that kind of like antibacterial and anti-inflammatory properties to help calm active breakout”▶ 3:20
- “I feel like this one does an amazing job at it, too”▶ 3:39
- “This formula actually includes ceramide as well to reinforce the barrier and hyaluronic acid for that hydration”▶ 4:04
- “As somebody with combination skin I love that”▶ 4:17
- “This gel cream just makes perfect sense”▶ 4:34
- “It's a lot more cosmetically elegant and wearable, but does the same job”
- “Gives you all the benefits of panthenol and centella, but in a much lighter formulation that is non-comedogenic”▶ 4:41
- “If you are prone to clogging pores, this might be a nice alternative”▶ 4:50
- “The Tea-Trica B5 gel cream is a really good option to try”▶ 5:15
- “I actually really enjoyed it”▶ 6:01
- “I liked it as a general nicely hydrating skin brightening product”▶ 6:05
- “It kind of just like made my skin look a bit fresher, not more even”▶ 6:11
- “It didn't get rid of hyperpigmentation, but my skin looked happy when I was using this”▶ 6:17
- “I do not think it's a go-to for pigmentation in my personal experience”▶ 6:22
- “The issue is for myself and many many people is it just doesn't deliver when it comes to fading stubborn dark spots like post acne marks melasma”▶ 6:52
- “It's a lovely texture, lovely, layers well with everything”▶ 7:17
- “For £52, the results just here didn't match the price tag for me”▶ 7:21
Abib$32.00- “This serum kind of uses like multiple pathways to target post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, redness, um pigmentation in general”▶ 7:35
- “There's something about the combination of all the ingredients in this one serum that I really, really loved for evening out skin tone”
- “It's very, very watery”
- “It's super fast absorbing”▶ 8:46
- “It literally just feels like water on the skin”▶ 8:49
- “Lays great under sunscreen and makeup”▶ 8:50
- “It's also so much more affordable”▶ 8:52
- “Affordability when it comes to serums that target things that take time, I think is really really important”▶ 9:13
- “This Vita drop serum gives you that broader ingredient lineup, a lighter texture at a much friendlier price point”▶ 9:25
- “Honestly, I just think it's the best one”▶ 9:31
COSRX$25.00- “It's a good product”
- “It's 96% snail secretion filtrate, which does give hydration and slight repairing benefits as well in that unique sim texture”▶ 10:37
- “I personally love it”
- “It's a really nice product”▶ 11:05
- “It's a quite simple formula which isn't a bad thing”▶ 11:09
- “I found in my experience it's one of those things that like you have to keep using it all the time to just feel hydrated”▶ 11:14
- “It can also feel sticky, which not a lot of people enjoy”▶ 11:35
- “COSRX is great if you're new to K-beauty, curious about snail mucin, or want a simple hydrator to pair with stronger actives”▶ 12:55
- “This actually uses a vegan alternative derived from snow fungus, which is really interesting”▶ 11:46
- “It's actually been shown to provide 9.7 times the soothing effect of heart leaf and over 100% more hydration than hyaluronic acid”▶ 11:59
- “You're not just getting hydration, you're getting targeted soothing for sensitive and easily irritated skin”▶ 12:07
- “VT's Essence has a more of like a lightweight, non-sticky finish that still gives you that hydrated, dewy look without feeling tacky”▶ 12:35
- “It's not sticky whatsoever”
- “For me is a better choice for much deeper hydration with that vegan option, too”▶ 13:13
Embryolisse$32.00- “It's often praised as like this multitasker. Moisturizer, primer, mask, and it does give the skin like a soft, nourished feel under makeup”▶ 13:27
- “It's effective”
- “It's fine um if you want that instantly smooth plump base, which is why makeup artists love it”▶ 13:47
- “It's a very old school emollient cream”
- “Rich and occlusive, but not particularly innovative when it comes to skin barrier support”▶ 13:25
- “For the price and the hype, you're mostly paying for its reputation as a backstage favorite at fashion shows”▶ 14:17
- “Some people like it and like I said, it's going to do the job very, very well”▶ 14:21
- “Embryolisse is kind of like rich and slightly greasy”▶ 15:39
S.NATURE$20.00- “The formula is way more advanced and it contains way more skin beneficial ingredients”▶ 14:41
- “Why not get a cream that's going to do the job and do more?”▶ 14:49
- “We have squalane in here again mimicking the skin's natural oils for deeper hydration and softness without the heaviness”
- “You have eight types of hyaluronic acid at different molecular weights meaning it's a little bit of deeper hydration but you're going to get that plumpness as well and that glow”▶ 15:00
- “We have a quaxel in here which goes a step further by improving water circulation and retention”▶ 15:09
- “Making this not just a fine moisturizer to use under makeup, but a treatment cream really for everything your skin could possibly want”▶ 15:28
- “S.Nature on the other hand feels weightless, watery, non-sticky and absorbs so quickly while still leaving skin really, really plump and hydrated”▶ 15:47
- “Great for makeup prep”▶ 15:45
- “It gives you that long lasting glass skin without feeling heavy and greasy”▶ 15:59
- “S.Nature's Aqua Squalane Cream is the much more, I guess you could say, modern choice”▶ 16:23
Caudalie$49.00- “It feels so outdated”
- “Is essentially a mix of like peppermint oil, rosemary, and a ton of fragrances that you don't really want in skin care or a product that you're going to be reapplying and reapplying and reapplying throughout the day”▶ 17:05
- “I find it absolutely horrific”▶ 17:21
- “It's minty. It's like spraying a cold mint all over your face, and you get a tingle, which is mostly from peppermint and alcohol”▶ 17:24
- “For sensitive skin, that combination of fragrance and essential oils in here is going to be more irritating than beneficial”▶ 17:36
- “This is on par for me with the Mario Badescu mist. You know, the flavored colored water that they offer”▶ 17:49
- “It's far more effective for doing what people want in a face mist. Hydration and soothing”▶ 18:09
- “You have that organic grape water in here, which is naturally rich in minerals, antioxidants”▶ 18:14
- “Caudalie also say prebiotics to support the skin's microbiome”▶ 18:20
- “Their own clinical studies show apparently it can reduce skin sensitivity by 61% and boost hydration by over 120%”▶ 18:30
- “There's no alcohol, which I don't mind alcohol at all, but they say it's alcohol-free, no fragrance in here, and no volatile oils, just a calming, refreshing mist that actually strengthens the skin instead of potentially irritating it”▶ 18:38
- “The grape water does the same job of refreshing the skin and providing an okayish base for makeup”▶ 19:11
- “If your goal is hydration, soothing, and makeup prep that actually benefits your skin, just give the water in a can a go”▶ 19:34
- “It's again a more modern choice and a gentler option for every skin type”▶ 19:43
More videos from James Welsh
Holy grail Korean skincare that transformed my skinJames Welsh
Testing overnight masks for better skin by morningJames Welsh
Best skincare products and tools of 2025James Welsh
5 overhyped skincare products and their better Korean dupesJames Welsh
10 Years of Viral Korean Skincare: Products That Survived the HypeJames Welsh
Overly sponsored skincare products: what's worth the hype and what's notJames WelshSimilar videos
I tried every viral setting sprayMorgan Turner
Best & Worst Vitamin C for Skin of ColourDr. Vanita Rattan
Will I Repurchase Any Empty Moisturizer? Skincare Trash TalkShelley Nayak
Every product I finished in 2025JUDY
Top 5 affordable Korean skincare brands for mature skinOne Eye Beauty
How to get glass skin for beginners: affordable skincare routine with Korean productskelly
Sephora Sale Faves for Every Concern from a DermatologistDr. Shereene Idriss
I tested 16 viral K-beauty moisturizers to find the #1 winnerCYoung
Best & worst moisturisers for oily acne skinDr. Vanita Rattan
Best and worst anti-aging and anti-pigmentation serums on NykaaDr. Vanita RattanQuotes are transcribed from the video; timestamps link to the moment. Browse everything James Welsh has reviewed.