- “The formula is comfortable but not very lasting”0:47–0:52
- “It doesn't look so impactful on me, although it depends if I'm wearing it with a base or not”0:49–0:57
- “With a base it looks very brown on me”0:54–0:59
- “I'm just genuinely not so much into it because I have some formulas that I love”1:03–1:06
- Source: Muted lip tints, glosses and lipsticks with stain test - Nov 2, 2025
Heart Percent
See reviews of these products
Browse more
Brand note
Heart Percent is a Korean brand that's built a real following around its lip pencils — specifically the retractable crayon format that creators describe as long-wearing, blurry, and easy to use daily. The Dote On Mood Lip Pencil Retractable Lip Crayon is the clear anchor: multiple creators call it a daily staple that works with any lip combo and lasts all day without reapplication. The trade-off is that the color on the packaging can be misleading, and the lip stain formula in the line is less impressive — comfortable but not lasting or impactful enough to compete with favorites.
Shop paths
Some links are affiliate links.
