- “These are basically just salicylic acids, 2% salicylic acid, and then it also has witch hazel in it. So, they can be drying if you use this too often or if your skin is more on the sensitive side”14:42–14:46
- “I think these are great. My skin does respond better to the Joah ones, so I think for like a similar effect, I would just go with the Joah”15:01–15:04
- “If I feel like my skin's in need of salicylic acid, would definitely repurchase”
- Source: 75+ products I've used up: biggest empties ever, would I repurchase? - Jan 8, 2026
Thayers
See Reviews of These Products
Browse More
Brand note
Thayers is a classic American skincare brand that's found its footing in the hydrating toner space, particularly with formulas that lean richer and more milky than the traditional witch-hazel-based toners they're known for. The Hydrating Milky Toner with Snow Mushroom is the standout here — creators consistently call it hydrating, plumping, and surprisingly good for a drugstore option, though it's thicker than a typical toner. The BHA pads exist but get a mixed reception: effective but potentially drying, and not everyone's first choice.
Shop Paths
Some links are affiliate links.
