- “The Dollar Tree version is really hard to spread unless it's warm”5:55–6:00
- “And nobody has time for that”6:00–6:02
- “I just want to apply it and go”
- “It wants me to save even more money by not letting me use it in the first place”6:01–6:06
- “And it'll last forever since it doesn't transfer well onto my skin”6:06–6:12
- “This was disappointment number one for me because before I tried it, I thought, how hard can it be to make a Vaseline stick? And the answer is it must be hard”6:10–6:16
- Source: Dermatologist Compares Dollar Tree vs High-End Skincare - Jan 24, 2026
Xtra Care
See reviews of these products
Browse more
- “I have used this lotion a few times, and I do feel like this helps to get rid of like bumps on your legs and on the back of your arms”5:24–5:30
- “I don't know that I will be like repurchasing any of the First Aid Beauty because this works just as good”5:36–5:46
- “I really like this from the Dollar Tree”5:43–5:49
- Source: Dollar Tree Makeup & Skincare Haul with Swatches - May 12, 2026
Brand note
Xtra Care is Dollar Tree's in-house skincare line, and the feedback here is pretty honest about what you're getting for a buck. The Revitalizing Body Balm Jelly Stick is a good example of the trade-off: it's a Vaseline-style stick that's genuinely hard to spread unless your skin or the room is warm, which makes it frustrating if you just want to slap it on and go. On the other hand, the Smoothing Body Lotion with 10% AHA actually works — creators say it smooths bumps on legs and arms comparably to First Aid Beauty's version, which is a solid win at this price point.

