WATERPROOF ASIAN MASCARA BATTLE OF THE BEST- CLIO, ROMAND, JUDY DOLL, HEROINE MAKE
Clio$21.60Kill Lash Superproof Mascarashade · 01 Long Curling- “This one actually has a slim curved fiber brush”▶ 1:19
- “The formula is called superproof, which means this mascara is supposed to not just be waterproof. It's also oilproof and humidity proof”▶ 1:26
- “So once it sets, it really locks your curl in place”▶ 1:36
- “The color is a deep jet black”▶ 1:42
- “This mascara focuses more on length and curl rather than heavy volume”▶ 1:45
- “I did three coats for all the mascaras and with Clio, this one lengthen my lashes up to my crease”▶ 1:52
- “It also separated them well with no clumps”▶ 1:57
- “I feel like this one gives that classic K drama lash look”▶ 2:00
- “After 4 hours, there's no smudging, but I see a small speck on each eye, which seems to be a bit of flaking, but it's very minimal”▶ 2:06
- “The biggest advantage I find with this mascara is that my curl is still fully lifted. Nothing has changed. It really kept my curl up”▶ 2:19
- “After 8 hours, it still looks almost the same. The curls, they're still locked in, but the lashes do feel slightly stiff”▶ 2:28
- “This Clio mascara is very waterproof. There was no transfer, but it was so hard to remove”▶ 2:42
- “I think that this is great for people with straight lashes because it has an amazing curl hold”▶ 3:37
- “If you want something long lasting, this is also really great”▶ 3:50
- “Because it's super proof and very longlasting, it's also very hard to remove”▶ 3:56
rom&nd$14.00Han All Fix Mascarashade · 02 Long Ash- “This one has a straight slim precision brush”▶ 4:30
- “The formula uses fixing polymers to hold the lashes up”▶ 4:33
- “The shade that I use is ash brown, so it looks softer than black”▶ 4:41
- “This one gives a very natural everyday lash look”▶ 4:46
- “With three coats, my lashes look longer. I think it's the same length as the Cleo. It's up to my crease, but the lashes ends, they look a bit bent”▶ 4:49
- “Because it's not jet black, the ash tone made it very soft and airy looking”▶ 5:04
- “After 4 hours, I found dark areas under my eyes, which looks like it's slight smudging”▶ 5:10
- “On the fourth hour, I also found that my curl is dropping a bit, but there's no flaking, only that slight smudging”▶ 5:54
- “After the eight hours, there is a slight curl drop again, but no additional smudging and no flaking”▶ 6:00
- “This one also passed my waterproof test. It didn't budge. It didn't transfer”▶ 6:08
- “It's much easier to remove than Cleo”▶ 6:19
- “I think that this one is really great for daily makeup because it looks very natural and it's also very easy to remove compared to the other mascaras that I have tried”▶ 6:30
- “This is also great for people who already have long and thick lashes and who just wants an extra oomph to their everyday look”▶ 6:44
- “Since the color is in the ash tone, don't expect this to look dramatic”▶ 6:54
- “If you have thin, sparse lashes, you might not appreciate this”▶ 7:00
Judydoll$12.00- “Judy Doll's main claim is Christian root lifting”▶ 7:24
- “It uses a very thin metal iron brush and the formula is fiberbased and waterproof”▶ 7:27
- “The color is also deep black just like Cleo”▶ 7:36
- “This one is amazing for short lashes because the brush coats every single lash”▶ 7:39
- “If you're like me who's a bit clumsy and always makes the spoolie touch your lid, this is great because the wand does not have any bristles on them”▶ 7:49
- “It's almost impossible that this would touch your crease”▶ 8:04
- “With three coats, this gave me the longest looking lashes, longer than how the other three mascaras did”▶ 8:36
- “This also separated my lashes the most”▶ 8:44
- “It looks like I have more lashes”▶ 8:50
- “There's also no clumps at all”▶ 8:52
- “After 4 hours, everything still looks sharp and there's absolutely no smudging, no flaking”▶ 8:55
- “After 8 hours, they are still lifted, clean, no smudging, no flaking”▶ 9:02
- “This one also passed my waterproof test”▶ 9:13
- “I can easily remove this with an eye makeup remover”▶ 9:19
- “I think this will be great if you want a very precise mascara application, if you have also short lashes because it really lengthens your lashes and if you like amazing separation between your lashes”▶ 9:38
KISS$17.99- “This one has a thick curved fiber brush. Actually, it's more tapered”▶ 10:27
- “It's a bit wet compared to the other three mascaras that I've tried, but it's super waterproof”▶ 10:36
- “The color is intense black”
- “With three coats, I find that this gave my lashes the most volume out of all the mascaras that I have tried in this video”▶ 10:43
- “My lashes look thicker”
- “The length I would say is the same as Cleo past the crease, but I find that the curl is better with Cleo than this because again, this one has a wetter formula than Cleo”▶ 10:56
- “For wear test after 4 hours, this still looks perfect. There's no smudging. There's no flaking”▶ 11:47
- “After eight hours, it still looks the same. No flaking, no smudging”▶ 11:53
- “This one is one of the hardest mascara to remove out of the four”▶ 12:03
- “This is a tad bit harder to remove than Cleo”▶ 12:12
- “You absolutely need this Heroin Make mascara remover to remove this because if you just use an eye makeup remover, an oil cleanser, and just double cleanse, I'm pretty sure the next day you would still feel this mascara on your lashes”▶ 12:15
- “I think this mascara is best for oily lids and for someone needing a mascara with extreme staying power”▶ 12:29
- “This is great because even if your crease tends to get oily, it wouldn't smudge”▶ 12:51
- “The staying power is really, really good”
- “It's also perfect for long days and events like wedding”▶ 13:03
More videos from Charisse Daily
Ranking viral milky skin toners best to worstCharisse Daily
12 Korean Skincare Products to Get K-pop Idol Glass SkinCharisse Daily
Best Western skincare of 2025: honest review + resultsCharisse Daily
Best Korean toners of 2025: honest reviews + resultsCharisse Daily
Best Korean Serums for Combination Acne-Prone Skin 2025Charisse Daily
Best Korean skincare products of the year: 2025Charisse Daily
Judydoll C-beauty brand review and Black Friday saleCharisse Daily
Best Korean Moisturizers for Oily SkinCharisse Daily
Top Korean serums for oily skinCharisse Daily
Best serums for fading acne spotsCharisse DailySimilar videos
Maybelline vs L'Oreal: Ultimate Drugstore ShowdownSophie 🎀
Speed reviews of over 75 viral makeup products part 2Sophie 🎀
Best of Beauty Awards in Japan 2025Tina Tanaka Harris
15 no fail makeup productsMakeup By Nikki La Rose
Overhyped beauty must haves I regret buying in 2025Sofia Sees Beauty
Allure Best of Beauty according to meMakeup By Nikki La Rose
Worst makeup of 2026Andréa Matillano
50 products I actually used up (beauty empties I loved + hated)Andréa Matillano
Best makeup of 2025sophdoeslife
The best makeup of 2025Carmel NicoleQuotes are transcribed from the video; timestamps link to the moment. Browse everything Charisse Daily has reviewed.