I Tried The Top 20 Tubing Mascaras And Found the Best One... Tubing Mascara Showdown!
Blinc$26.00- “This has a pretty standard tapered wand with bristles that essentially disappear the further away you get from the handle”▶ 0:16
- “The wand itself is really really flexible”▶ 0:27
- “I honestly think that this wand is just way too flimsy to give good results”▶ 0:33
- “The formula is thin and very dry which I find makes it very difficult to build”▶ 0:43
- “The length is so so bad”
- “It just makes my lashes look way too short”▶ 1:10
- “It literally disappeared from my lashes by the end of the day”
- “That is the biggest reason why I felt like I had no choice but to give this last place”▶ 1:51
- “The wand is slightly curved with really soft nylon bristles but it's a huge problem because of how much product gets stuck to it”▶ 2:09
- “It's a drier formula that is so thick and sticky and that makes both coating and building my lashes with this mascara really difficult”▶ 2:24
- “The length is not only not good but also super inconsistent”▶ 2:44
- “The clumping is so so bad”
- “I honestly could not care less how this removes because I hate the way it looks from the second I apply it to the end of the day”▶ 3:07
- “Awful can't recommend it any less”▶ 3:12
- “The formula is such an issue. It's very wet. It's the kind of formula that immediately starts to transfer if you blink while you're applying it”▶ 3:31
- “It's thick but it doesn't layer well”▶ 3:38
- “Length is average. Some of my lashes look nice and long but it's super inconsistent”▶ 3:49
- “Separation is not good. There are a lot of areas where my lashes are just clumped together”▶ 4:00
- “I just think this overall look is bad”▶ 4:10
- “It does fully tube off while removing it, but that is pretty much the only redeeming quality this mascara has”▶ 4:20
tarte$28.00Tartelette Tubing Mascarashade · XL- “The formula leans both wet and thick so it's definitely one that starts to feel a bit heavy when layered”▶ 4:36
- “The length is good and yes there's a ton of volume but the separation is not good”▶ 4:52
- “I think this just looks kind of short and clumpy”▶ 4:57
- “I think it actually stays in place pretty well but it's just that I don't like the way it looks”▶ 5:22
- “I would definitely pass on the Tartelette XL especially because I think that the original Tartelette mascara is significantly better”▶ 5:34
KVD Beauty$25.00- “I hate this wand I just don't understand the purpose of a design like this”▶ 5:46
- “the formula is kind of tough”▶ 6:07
- “it's very very wet so because of that it starts to clump as you layer”▶ 6:13
- “the length is really good in some places but again is too inconsistent”▶ 6:23
- “the overall look is just not for me I think it looks a little bit spiky clumpy and too straight like there's zero curl going on here”▶ 6:35
- “this doesn't even wear well it actually flakes quite a bit on me”▶ 6:44
- “KVD full sleeve is not something I could ever recommend”▶ 6:53
Essence$4.97- “The formula is dry and very thin so layering it doesn't really add much volume”▶ 7:07
- “Separation is definitely better than a lot of the others”▶ 7:11
- “Both the length and volume are pretty average for me”▶ 7:15
- “The overall look is definitely just a bit prettier because it's more curled and fluffy”▶ 7:20
- “The wear is so so so bad”
L.A. Girl$8.00- “I absolutely hate this wand it's too Pokey it's too bulky and it's too flimsy”▶ 7:43
- “the length is good the volume is good but the separation is average”▶ 7:56
- “it looks gross by the end of the day like it just looks spidery”▶ 8:10
- “it not only does not fully tube off it smudges and it burns the heck out of my eyes”▶ 7:30
- “I will never use this ever again it was a huge fail for me”▶ 8:24
Judydoll$12.00- “I for one hate it it's completely metal and there are no bristles”▶ 8:45
- “I got so many fibers in my eyes while applying this because there's no bristles”▶ 8:59
- “The formula itself is actually nice it's not too dry and not too wet it's not too thin and not too thick”▶ 9:05
- “I was actually able to get good length and good volume but the separation is just not so great”▶ 9:12
- “The curl is actually really pretty it has nice left for sure”▶ 9:22
- “This one majorly fades on me by the end of the day”▶ 9:24
- “I cannot get this to remove on me with just warm water I need makeup remover”▶ 9:30
Ulta Beauty Collection$12.00- “The formula leans dry but it's not too dry and it's also not too thin and not too thick so it's definitely one of the better formulas out of everything I've talked about so far”▶ 10:07
- “Initially I think that the length is great the volume is great and the separation is great too so pretty”▶ 10:12
- “The wear is not good at all it makes my lashes look so short by the end of the day”▶ 10:21
- “When I try to remove this it does not come off in tubes at all it just smudges everywhere”▶ 10:28
- “This had a lot of potential it looked so nice at first it's just not one that stands the test of time”▶ 10:37
L'Oreal Paris$12.99- “The formula is not too dry and not too wet but thin so I wasn't really able to layer it up a ton”▶ 11:20
- “It's one that is more natural for sure”▶ 11:26
- “It has I would say like average to good length depending on the lash”▶ 11:29
- “The volume is good and the separation is good though”▶ 11:33
- “I think that this is pretty for a more natural option it's soft it has that wispy effect”▶ 11:37
- “The wear is fine I did have some flakes but nothing major”▶ 11:45
- “This one fully removes in tubes”▶ 11:51
- “While this is not one that I'm going to continue reaching for I could definitely see some of you really enjoying it because of that more natural curled look”▶ 11:53
Merit$26.00- “The formula is one that is not too dry and not too wet but very thin so I did have to layer this up significantly more than the others”▶ 12:11
- “Length is average to good again depending on the lash”▶ 12:18
- “Volume I think is good it's definitely one that is like fluffier and has more of that false lash effect”▶ 12:20
- “Separation I would say is average to good some areas are too clumped but that left eye looks amazing”▶ 12:27
- “Wear I would say is okay it definitely does fade but it's not as bad as some of the others”▶ 12:38
- “Removal is an issue though not only does it not tube off and ends up smudging but it stings my eyes as well”▶ 12:44
Milk Makeup$29.00- “The formula is not too thin and not too thick and it leans dry”▶ 13:31
- “The length is good but the volume is a lot and I feel like it's too much for me personally”▶ 13:41
- “Separation is just kind of average like it's just a clumpier thicker looking mascara”▶ 13:50
- “My lashes look way too straight like I don't get any curl with this”▶ 13:55
- “The wear is pretty good though and removal is easy it comes off fully in tubes”▶ 13:58
- “This may be one that you're interested in if you like a bolder lash look like this it's just not for me”▶ 14:02
Clinique$28.00- “The formula is wet but the thickness is just right it's not too thin and it's not too thick”▶ 14:15
- “I think the length is great and the volume is good but the separation is average”▶ 14:19
- “It falls flat for me it just is a little too clumpy”▶ 14:22
- “This one does definitely fade quite a bit on me by the end of the day”▶ 14:33
- “I almost kind of like it better like some of that intensity has worn off”▶ 14:40
- “This one does take a bit more effort to remove but it does fully come off in tubes”▶ 14:43
Caliray$25.00- “The formula is wet but again not too thin and not too thick”▶ 15:01
- “The length is good, the volume is great, and the separation is good”▶ 15:04
- “Overall I think this looks really pretty, I love the curl with it”▶ 15:07
- “The wear is just not as good as I want it to be”▶ 15:11
- “It did fully come off in tubes”▶ 14:48
- “The formula is just right, it's not too thin and not too thick, it's not too dry and not too wet, and it layers really well”▶ 15:59
- “The length is great and the volume is good”▶ 16:05
- “I would say where this falls flat is with separation. I think I get like average to good separation”▶ 16:07
- “The wear is pretty good and this fully removes in tubes”▶ 16:20
- “If you're looking for the tubing mascara in this video that performs well and is the most affordable, this is going to be the one for you”▶ 16:24
Heimish$16.49- “The length is amazing and the volume is amazing as well”▶ 16:47
- “Separation I would say is average, it definitely is just a little bit clumpy all over”▶ 16:49
- “It has really pretty curl”▶ 17:01
- “It looks like I had the most amazing lash day ever but then I cried and some of my lashes stuck together”▶ 17:04
- “Wear is pretty good, I would say it fades but there are no major issues”▶ 17:14
- “It still fully comes off in tubes”▶ 17:24
- “This is definitely a really solid tubing mascara and one of the best in this video”▶ 17:27
Hourglass$34- “The formula is not too thin not too thick not too dry and not too wet but there is something about it that's a little bit sticky”▶ 18:03
- “The length is amazing”▶ 18:11
- “The volume I actually rated higher when I was comparing it to all of these mascaras in this video”▶ 18:13
- “Separation here I think is like average to good it could definitely be better”▶ 18:28
- “For wear I think that it does hold up really well and it's super easy to remove it fully comes off in tubes”▶ 18:36
- “A great tubing mascara”▶ 18:43
Thrive Causemetics$15.98- “The formula leans thick and is very wet”▶ 19:10
- “The length is amazing and the volume is amazing”▶ 19:19
- “The separation is average to good. I think it just looks a little bit spidery, a little bit clumpy”▶ 19:21
- “The length and curl are so good, so I understand why so many people love this mascara”▶ 19:30
- “It definitely did fade more than I was hoping”▶ 19:40
- “The removal for this is so so easy. It fully comes off in tubes, definitely one of the easiest to remove”▶ 19:42
- “I definitely understand the hype behind this mascara. I think it is a really really good one”▶ 19:49
- “This one actually leans a little bit drier and a little bit thinner than some of the others”▶ 20:20
- “It does dry down pretty fast so just make sure to work with it quickly if you want to add layers”▶ 20:37
- “The length is amazing, the volume is great, and the separation is good”▶ 20:45
- “I'm honestly surprised by how separated this looks given the wand”▶ 20:51
- “It does fade but I don't have any major issues with wear”▶ 21:02
- “It mostly removes in tubes completely”
- “I think it's an amazing mascara”▶ 21:17
tarte$28.00- “This is a thicker formula that is not too dry and not too wet and it layers so so well”▶ 21:58
- “Lengths amazing, volume's amazing, and separation is amazing”▶ 22:06
- “The wear could definitely be better of course, I mean wear for all of these could be better, but I think comparatively it holds up really well”▶ 22:08
- “Removal for this one might be a deal breaker for some of you because it like partially tubes mostly smears off, but it still comes off super easily”▶ 22:16
- “This is without a doubt the best tubing mascara I have ever tried”▶ 22:37
More videos from Abbey Yung
E.L.F. Haircare Dupes vs High-End: Ingredient ComparisonAbbey Yung
I tested 30 viral hair products so you don't have toAbbey Yung
Best Amazon Prime Day 2026 Beauty DealsAbbey Yung
Everyday drugstore makeup routineAbbey Yung
Beauty empties 2026: haircare, skincare, bodycare, and makeup products I've used upAbbey Yung
I tried 27 new drugstore beauty launchesAbbey Yung
The PM Skincare Routine That Gave Me the Best Skin of My LifeAbbey Yung
The best new products I've tried in a long timeAbbey Yung
The drugstore can’t dupe these products from the Sephora Sale…Abbey Yung
Pass or Repurchase: Top 30 New Beauty LaunchesAbbey YungSimilar videos
Maybelline vs L'Oreal: Ultimate Drugstore ShowdownSophie 🎀
Speed reviews of over 75 viral makeup products part 2Sophie 🎀
June 2026 empties worth $1000Vivian Nguyen
15 no fail makeup productsMakeup By Nikki La Rose
Overhyped beauty must haves I regret buying in 2025Sofia Sees Beauty
Allure Best of Beauty according to meMakeup By Nikki La Rose
Worst makeup of 2026Andréa Matillano
50 products I actually used up (beauty empties I loved + hated)Andréa Matillano
Best makeup of 2025sophdoeslife
The best makeup of 2025Carmel NicoleQuotes are transcribed from the video; timestamps link to the moment. Browse everything Abbey Yung has reviewed.