GrailPeople

MAKE UP FOR EVER

Ask to find reviews

See Reviews of These Products

@taylorwynn reviewing MAKE UP FOR EVER Extreme Pencil at 14:54 in a YouTube Shorts videoArtist Color Pencil"Ride or die. Ride or die pencil."$27.00@moorebeautifully reviewing MAKE UP FOR EVER Artist Color Pencils Extreme at 55:58 in a YouTube Shorts videoArtist Color Pencil Extreme Smudge-Proof Lip Liner"These are gorgeous. They don't run. This has been sitting on my lips now for hours and they are beautiful."$25.55@erinnicoletv reviewing MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Resist Color Pencil at 18:56 in a YouTube Shorts videoAqua Resist Color Pencil"It's not as precise as the Aura Mexico I tried last week, but I still really like it."-@jooshica6178 reviewing MAKE UP FOR EVER Pencil Eyeliner at 09:36 in a YouTube Shorts videoAqua XL Extra Long Lasting Waterproof Eye Pencil"The pigment screams pigment. Take a look. Oh my god. Take a look at this pigment, guys. I didn't even draw it hard. Like, I am drawing it so softly."$25.00@juliaadamsmua reviewing MAKE UP FOR EVER Mini Holiday Kit Eyeliners at 12:10 in a YouTube Shorts videoArtist Color Pencil Magic Mini Set"Really nice to just have in the makeup bag."$29.00

Browse More

Artist Color Pencil
4.9Variant: Wherever WalnutArtist Color Pencil
Laura LavigneLaura Lavigne2.4K subscribers
4.8Variant: ExtremeArtist Color Pencil
Erin Nicole TVErin Nicole TV130K subscribers
4.8Variant: Extreme / Anywhere CaffeineArtist Color Pencil
By Kristina StudioBy Kristina Studio66K subscribers
4.5Variant: 610 Versatile ChestnutArtist Color Pencil
  • “I think this is most versatile lip liner that I own, and also just a variation on the MAC Chestnut”11:22–11:31
  • “They apply beautifully, blend nicely, stay on for quite a good amount of time”11:51–11:57
  • “I've been using this one a lot with my combinations, either with a gloss or with a lipstick, like very versatile”11:57–12:04
  • “It literally the name also says it, versatile chestnut, but it is actually versatile, like legit versatile”12:04–12:10
  • Source: March 2026 Beauty Favorites - Mar 22, 2026
Angela OnuohaAngela Onuoha18K subscribers
4.5Variant: Extreme / 506 Endless CacaoArtist Color Pencil
  • “This one specific shade is very unique and you can only find from this brand at Sephora”19:41–19:50
  • “This shade is more like cool tone brown color that you can't really find from other drugstore brand, and I never seen this type of color from other Sephora brands as well”19:54–20:02
  • “This is very unique cool tone lip liner that's so rare to find”20:03–20:10
  • “I found that most of brown lip liner or brown base lip liners are warm tone base, so sometimes they look super warm or too super orange on my lips, but I found it this creates most natural looking shadow or contour my lips”20:08–20:15
  • “This is like multi-purpose pencil, so you can actually use this as a eyeliner or eyeshadow as well”20:23–20:29
  • “Even if you put it as a eyeliner, it looks also very unique and very pretty, and looks pretty chic compared to other brown base eyeliner”20:31–20:39
  • “I think this shade Endless Cacao and this specific liner is just perfect multi-purpose pencil”
  • Source: Sephora Sale Recommendations: What's Actually Worth Buying - Apr 11, 2026
Haley KimHaley Kim1.4M subscribers
4Variant: Extreme / Anywhere CaffeineArtist Color Pencil
Matilda on VideoMatilda on Video340K subscribers
2.5Variant: Wherever WalnutArtist Color Pencil
lynjianglynjiang4.5K subscribers
Artist Color Pencil Extreme Smudge-Proof Lip Liner
Aqua Resist Color Pencil
Aqua XL Extra Long Lasting Waterproof Eye Pencil
4.9Aqua XL Extra Long Lasting Waterproof Eye Pencil
JooshicaJooshica2.8M subscribers
Artist Color Pencil Magic Mini Set
Brand note

MAKE UP FOR EVER is a pro-oriented brand whose Artist Color Pencil Extreme Smudge-Proof Lip Liner is the clear anchor — a multi-use matte pencil creators use on lips, eyes, and even cheeks, praised for its versatility, pigmentation, and unique cool-toned brown shades that are hard to find elsewhere. The Super Boost Lip Gloss gets mixed feedback: some love the juicy, non-sticky finish, while others find it thin, fragranced, and underwhelming in product amount. Overall, the brand delivers reliable, no-fuss color products that work across features, but the gloss formula may not suit everyone.

Shop Paths

MAKE UP FOR EVER SiteAmazonSephoraStylevanaNordstromMake Up For Ever

Some links are affiliate links.