See reviews of these products

Browse more

3.5Variant: BlackAutomatic Eyeliner Pencil
3.5Variant: Better Than BurgundyAutomatic Eyeliner Pencil
  • “I have tried L.A. Colors auto eyeliner. I thought it was okay, so maybe this one will be even better”5:51–5:56
  • “It is like a true kind of burgundy”6:07–6:12
  • “I don't know actually if I like that with my eye color and my eyes. I think it might actually make my eyes look like they're red to be honest”6:11–6:19
  • “Not a bad eyeliner. It's just the color”6:24–6:27
  • “This kind of just makes my eyes look very red, pink eyeish. I don't like it”6:29–6:36
  • “I did try that L.A. Colors auto eyeliner. I don't think this is bad. I just didn't like that burgundy color with my eye color”17:34–17:37
  • “I just felt like it instead of making them pop, it just made them look so red and a little irritated. So, I didn't love this for that reason”17:36–17:44
  • Source: Full Face of New Dollar Tree Makeup Hits & Misses - Nov 10, 2025
Brand note

L.A. Colors is the budget brand that keeps surprising creators with genuinely good quality at Dollar Tree prices. The eyeshadow quads get the most buzz — they're described as pigmented, buttery, and consistent, with a formula that's improved noticeably over the years. The Sculpting Duo is a solid bronzer/highlight option that blends easily and lasts, though some shades run warm or glittery. If you're willing to dig through the racks, you can find real gems, but expect occasional duds and fallout on darker shadows.

Shop paths

Some links are affiliate links.