See reviews of these products

Browse more

4.9Exaggerate Waterproof Eyeliner
4.9Variant: BrownExaggerate Waterproof Eyeliner
  • “The Rimmel exaggerate waterproof eye pencil is one of the best, if not, I think the best drugstore eyeliner, and you can get it at Five Below”5:10–5:17
  • “I love this eyeliner because it is so creamy”5:41–5:46
  • “It's all around just a really great eyeliner. It also lasts really well. Like it really is waterproof”5:53–5:59
  • “Rimmel liner, I told you guys is incredible. If you ever see this there and you're in the market for a retractable waterproof eyeliner”18:45–18:50
  • Source: Testing viral Five Below dupes - Apr 25, 2026
Brand note

Rimmel is a drugstore brand that consistently delivers on pigment and value, especially in their complexion and lip categories. The Multi-Tasker Better than Filters Face Primer is a standout for giving a natural, healthy glow without glitter or heavy coverage, often compared to higher-end alternatives. Their lip liners and bronzing stick also get strong praise for creamy texture and lasting power. If you're looking for affordable, reliable basics that perform above their price point, Rimmel is a solid bet.

Shop paths

Some links are affiliate links.