See Reviews of These Products

Browse More

4.9Tartelette Tubing Mascara
mentionsTartelette Tubing Mascara
  • “I am a tubing mascara devotee, especially the older I've gotten”5:15–5:21
  • “I do not need any help with dark circles under my eyes from fallout from mascara”5:23–5:28
  • “Tubing mascara literally forms tubes over your eyelashes and then they're resistant to water up to a certain point and it's also not going to smudge or flake or any of that stuff”5:35–5:42
  • “I believe that it's also really good for eyelash health because you're not tugging and ripping at your eyelashes with an eye makeup remover”5:52–5:57
  • “I can't tell you the last time I had to do this around my eyes. I'm talking years and years and I truly believe that not doing that to my eye area has contributed to my eye area looking a little bit better”6:02–6:09
  • Source: Prime Day Beauty Part 2: Makeup, Hair & Fragrance Deals - Jun 24, 2026
2.5Variant: XLTartelette Tubing Mascara
  • “The formula leans both wet and thick so it's definitely one that starts to feel a bit heavy when layered”4:36–4:41
  • “The length is good and yes there's a ton of volume but the separation is not good”4:52–4:57
  • “I think this just looks kind of short and clumpy”4:57–5:01
  • “I think it actually stays in place pretty well but it's just that I don't like the way it looks”5:22–5:29
  • “I would definitely pass on the Tartelette XL especially because I think that the original Tartelette mascara is significantly better”5:34–5:37
  • Source: Best tubing mascara showdown: top 20 tested - Jul 24, 2024
2.5Tartelette Tubing Mascara
  • “This is a thicker formula that is not too dry and not too wet and it layers so so well”21:58–22:06
  • “Lengths amazing, volume's amazing, and separation is amazing”22:06–22:11
  • “The wear could definitely be better of course, I mean wear for all of these could be better, but I think comparatively it holds up really well”22:08–22:14
  • “Removal for this one might be a deal breaker for some of you because it like partially tubes mostly smears off, but it still comes off super easily”22:16–22:22
  • “This is without a doubt the best tubing mascara I have ever tried”22:37–22:44
  • Source: Best tubing mascara showdown: top 20 tested - Jul 24, 2024
4.8Lights, Camera, Lashes Platinum Volumizing Mascara
Brand note

Tarte is a brand that gets brought up for two very different things: a color corrector that actually hydrates and a concealer that some people swear by and others find unwearable. The Colored Clay CC Undereye Corrector is the real standout — it's thick and tacky but doesn't dry out the under-eye, and it cancels dark circles without settling into lines, though you'll usually need concealer on top. On the other hand, the Shape Tape concealer splits opinion hard: some call it the best ever, others find it revolting and claggy, so it's very much a try-before-you-buy situation.

Shop Paths

Some links are affiliate links.