See Reviews of These Products

Browse More

4.9Variant: FaunEye Stylus Shadow Stick
4.9Variant: AdornEye Stylus Shadow Stick
  • “I have been absolutely obsessed with Look how pretty that is”15:35–15:40
  • “I feel like it just looks so pretty, but it's not super extreme on me. So, it isn't so bright that it's looking crazy, but it has such a nice brightness to it”
  • “It is such Look how pretty that shade is. It's just ridiculous”16:04–16:09
  • “These build up really nicely. So, it might be more at first it might be a little bit more subtle looking, but you can really build them up”
  • “This just gives me the most beautiful eye look. And just wearing it on its own is also so nice”16:26–16:33
  • Source: Best new makeup I've tried recently - May 19, 2026
4.8Variant: OpulentEye Stylus Shadow Stick
4.8Variant: OpulentEye Stylus Shadow Stick
  • “What really deserves kudos is the shimmer formula of the Ilia eyeshadow sticks because they are the only eyeshadow stick like true eyeshadow stick”28:40–28:47
  • “The shimmer actually stays are the Ilia ones. The shimmer stays. It doesn't like blend away”28:57–29:06
  • “I swatched them on the back of my hand and then tried to wash them off with soap and hot water and they wouldn't come off”29:06–29:10
  • “I just think that they are a triumph”29:12–29:15
  • “I reach for them constantly”
  • Source: Best of the best makeup of 2025 - Dec 19, 2025
Brand note

Ilia is a clean beauty brand that's genuinely good at a few specific things — the Super Serum Skin Tint SPF 40 is a standout for its natural, skin-like finish and medium coverage that doesn't oxidize, though it can feel oily or irritating for some. The Soft Focus Blurring Blush actually blurs texture and pores without shimmer, and the Eye Stylus Shadow Sticks are impressively budge-proof. The trade-off: performance can be inconsistent across the line, and the shade range for deeper skin tones has been called out as lacking.

Shop Paths

Some links are affiliate links.